NSF 的 X-Labs 项目获慈善机构与投资者支持

美国国家科学基金会资助高风险 X-Labs —— IEEE Spectrum
NSF 的 X-Labs 计划获得慈善机构和投资者支持
面向技术内行
面向技术内行
IEEE Spectrum 是 IEEE 的旗舰出版物,IEEE 是全球最大的致力于工程与应用科学的专业组织。我们的文章、视频和信息图向读者介绍技术、工程和科学领域的最新进展。
创建账户,即可享受更多免费内容和权益
保存文章以便稍后阅读需要拥有 IEEE Spectrum 账户
The Institute 的内容仅对会员开放
下载完整的 PDF 期刊仅限 IEEE 会员
下载本电子书仅限 IEEE 会员
访问 Spectrum 数字版仅限 IEEE 会员
关注主题是 IEEE 会员专属功能
加入全球最大的致力于工程与应用科学的专业组织,即可访问 Spectrum 的全部文章、存档、PDF 下载及其他权益。进一步了解 IEEE →
加入全球最大的致力于工程与应用科学的专业组织,即可获取本电子书以及 IEEE Spectrum 的全部文章、存档、PDF 下载及其他权益。进一步了解 IEEE →
访问数千篇文章——完全免费
创建账户即可获得专属内容和功能:保存文章、下载合集、发表评论——全部免费!如需完整访问权限和全部权益,请订阅 Spectrum。
NSF 的 X-Labs 计划获得慈善机构与投资者支持
“联盟合作伙伴”旨在帮助科学家在激进的时限内开展高风险研究
Lucas Laursen 是 IEEE Spectrum 的技术政策编辑。
Matt Cimaglia 与同事在得克萨斯州奥斯汀即将建成的 Occam Foundry 场地交谈,这里是 X-Labs 的潜在地点。
当美国国家科学基金会(NSF)于5月启动其 X-Labs 计划时,该机构表示,这些风险更高、资助力度更大的奖项将创建新型合作伙伴关系,以应对紧迫的科学与技术挑战。如今,NSF 正加倍押注这一理念,于10月宣布慈善机构、企业和投资基金将为 X-Lab 获奖者提供实际支持,例如实验室空间、软件、共享设备,以及获取关键数据和专家指导的渠道。
这些被 NSF 称为“联盟合作伙伴”的组织所提供的帮助,不会让它们获得 X-Labs 项目的所有权股份。引入联盟合作伙伴可能有助于首批获奖者达成那些竞争金额大得多的 5000 万美元多年期拨款所需的激进目标——首批获奖者将于11月晚些时候或12月公布,他们将获得 150 万美元用于为期9个月的规划阶段。
“这是一种告诉 X-Labs 申请者的方式:你不必重复造轮子,这样你就不用把一半的 X-Labs 资金花在建造或购买基础基础设施上,”联盟合作伙伴 Occam Foundry 和 Florida Quantum Center 的投资人 Matt Cimaglia 说。
NSF X-Labs 聚焦 AI、计算等领域
NSF 最初公布了 X-Labs 项目的两个重点领域:用于传感与成像的科学仪器,以及用于量子系统的光子微芯片。9 月,该机构又追加了三个领域:面向物理设备的 AI、解码生物序列,以及突破计算的物理极限。
NSF 要求潜在的 X-Labs 资助对象最终展现出自主性:例如,项目负责人必须全职投入这项工作,并且必须能够独立于任何大学或商业所有者做出招聘和支出决策。这种敏捷性,连同其风险偏好,正是 X-Labs 与众不同之处。
联盟合作伙伴看到了提供基础设施与运营支持、让 X-Labs 资助对象得以专注研究的潜力。“(我们)对研发的赋能型架构非常感兴趣,”参与合作的伙伴之一斯隆基金会(Sloan Foundation)的项目主任 Joshua M. Greenberg 说。
Greenberg 表示,该基金会已经支持了多家聚焦研究组织(focused research organizations,简称 FROs)。FROs 是独立实体,与 X-Labs 项目希望创建的形式类似。与大学实验室或大型科技公司不同,FROs 成立时有着明确时限的目标,即在界定清晰的领域推进研究。由于是从零开始,FROs 可能缺乏大学或企业研究团队可能继承的基础设施。为解决基础设施不足的问题,位于波士顿的生物工程服务公司 Ginkgo Bioworks 正向 X-Lab 获奖者提供价值高达 500 万美元的“云实验室”使用权限,该公司首席执行官兼创始人 Jason Kelly 表示。Ginkgo 的云实验室能够开展复杂且灵活的实验室工作,公司还将提供实验室空间和内部数据集,这些可能对训练 AI 模型有用。Kelly 对 X-Labs 的潜力充满热情,他表示,X-Labs 有潜力像联邦人类基因组计划曾经那样“催生平台”,后者促成了大量后续创新。
Kelly 说,随着科学与技术公司变得越来越强大,政府重新审视如何让它们参与政府主导的科学研究,是很自然的事。“如今公司的规模已不同于万尼瓦尔·布什时代[20 世纪 40 年代],”他说,“那么美国应当如何利用那些[规模大得多、能力也强得多的]公司?把它们晾在一边是愚蠢的。”1945 年,万尼瓦尔·布什撰写了一份颇具影响力的报告,帮助塑造了现代 NSF 和美国联邦科研资助体系。白宫科技政策办公室主任 Michael Kratsios 在 7 月发布的一份报告,提出了现任政府对更新布什报告的构想,其中包括 X-Labs 所扮演的角色。
亚利桑那州立大学(ASU)美国技术政策史学者 Arthur Daemmrich 表示,他欢迎本届政府愿意在科研资助上进行试验。“这个领域已经变得非常因循守旧……本届政府有一股我在历届政府身上都没见过的活力。”他还指出,X-Labs 开展科研的方式“就像是科学领域的零工”,因此它可能适用于某些人和某些问题,却未必适用于另一些人和另一些问题。
曾任 NASA 项目经理、现为 Daemmrich 在 ASU 同事的 Zachary Pirtle 说,这些规模更大的项目对社会做出的贡献也值得研究,尽管究竟该如何研究仍是个未解的问题。“如果你资助这些了不起的团队,并希望他们造福社会,那就不能只有工程师和科学家。是否需要在其中一些团队里配备经济学家?或者各类不同的社会科学家?”
学术界拥抱 X-Labs 的 AI 模式
一些学者正在拥抱 X-Labs 模式。Nathalie Risso 是亚利桑那大学图森分校的电气工程师,从事采矿设备自动化的应用研究。Risso 正以“AI for physical systems”主题提交申请,目标是测试重型采矿设备的自学习 AI 运行。
“X-Labs 让我们能够探索那些规模超出实验室能力的项目,或者那些我们本可以在矿山完成的事,但他们不会让我们使用他们的选矿厂,因为那太贵了,”她说。把这件事做成的成本超过了一所大学通常的资助额度,而做错的代价则超出任何产业合作方愿意承担的风险。
支持者表示,这类被错失的机会恰恰说明,设立一个 X-Labs 规模的项目是有必要的。X-labs 联盟的另一家合作方 Secunda Family Foundation 的一位发言人称,AI 正是让 NSF 这一做法显得如此紧迫的部分原因。“AI 和其他新技术正在迅速改变科学家能够尝试的范围,但支撑科研的基础设施和制度必须随之演进。”
“工程师们应该为这样一件事感到兴奋:拥有创业心态的人现在有了开放的新机会,”Cimaglia 说,“你不必非得是某所大学的一员。”
Greenberg 对此表示赞同。“这更像是创办一个新组织,而不是推介一个具体的研究项目。”
译文由英文原文机器翻译,术语按行业惯例统一,可在文末展开原文核对。
查看英文原文(NSF’s X-Labs Program Draws Support From Charities and Investors)
National Science Foundation Fuels High-Risk X-Labs - IEEE Spectrum
NSF’s X-Labs Program Draws Support From Charities and Investors
FOR THE TECHNOLOGY INSIDER
FOR THE TECHNOLOGY INSIDER
IEEE Spectrum is the flagship publication of the IEEE — the world’s largest professional organization devoted to engineering and applied sciences. Our articles, videos, and infographics inform our readers about developments in technology, engineering, and science.
Enjoy more free content and benefits by creating an account
Saving articles to read later requires an IEEE Spectrum account
The Institute content is only available for members
Downloading full PDF issues is exclusive for IEEE Members
Downloading this e-book is exclusive for IEEE Members
Access to Spectrum 's Digital Edition is exclusive for IEEE Members
Following topics is a feature exclusive for IEEE Members
Join the world’s largest professional organization devoted to engineering and applied sciences and get access to all of Spectrum’s articles, archives, PDF downloads, and other benefits. Learn more about IEEE →
Join the world’s largest professional organization devoted to engineering and applied sciences and get access to this e-book plus all of IEEE Spectrum’s articles, archives, PDF downloads, and other benefits. Learn more about IEEE →
Access Thousands of Articles — Completely Free
Create an account and get exclusive content and features: Save articles, download collections, and post comments — all free! For full access and benefits, subscribe to Spectrum .
NSF’s X-Labs Program Draws Support From Charities and Investors
“Consortium partners” aim to help scientists conduct high-risk research on aggressive timelines
Lucas Laursen is the technology policy editor at IEEE Spectrum.

Matt Cimaglia and colleagues speak at the site of the forthcoming Occam Foundry in Austin, Texas, a potential site for X-Labs.
When the U.S. National Science Foundation began its X-Labs program in May, the agency said the higher-risk, higher-funded awards would create new kinds of partnerships that would confront urgent scientific and technological challenges. Now, the NSF is doubling down on the idea, with an announcement in October that charities, companies, and investment funds would provide X-Lab winners practical support such as laboratory space, software, shared equipment, and access to key data and expert guidance.
The help provided by these organizations, which the NSF is calling “consortium partners,” will not give them ownership stakes in the X-Labs projects. The addition of the consortium partners may help the initial winners—who will be announced later in November or December and who receive US $1.5 million for a 9-month planning phase—reach the aggressive targets needed to compete for much larger $50 million multi-year grants.
“It’s a way of telling X-Labs applicants you don’t need to reinvent the wheel, so you’re not spending half of your X-Labs money to go build or buy basic infrastructure,” says Matt Cimaglia, an investor in consortium partners Occam Foundry and Florida Quantum Center.
NSF X-Labs Focus on AI, Computing, and More
The NSF initially announced two focus areas for the X-Labs program: scientific instruments for sensing and imaging and photonic microchips for quantum systems. In September, the agency followed up with three additional areas in AI for physical devices, decoding biological sequences, and pushing the physical limits of computing.
The NSF requires potential X-Labs award recipients to eventually demonstrate autonomy: Leaders for projects must be focused on the work full-time, for example, and must be able to make hiring and spending decisions independently from any university or commercial owners. That agility sets X-Labs apart, along with the risk appetite.
Consortium partners saw the potential to provide infrastructure and operations support to allow X-Labs recipients to focus on research. “[We’re] very interested in the enabling structures of R&D,” says Joshua M. Greenberg, program director at the Sloan Foundation, one of the participating partners.
Greenberg says that the foundation has supported multiple focused research organizations, or FROs, already. FROs are independent entities in the same vein as what the X-Labs program hopes to create. Unlike university laboratories or larger tech companies, FROs are founded with a time-limited purpose of advancing research in a well-defined area. Because they start with a clean slate, FROs may lack the infrastructure that university or corporate research groups might inherit.
To address that lack of infrastructure, bioengineering service firm Ginkgo Bioworks, in Boston, is offering X-Lab winners up to $5 million worth of access to its “cloud lab,” says Jason Kelly, the firm’s CEO and founder. Ginkgo’s cloud lab can conduct complex and flexible laboratory work, and the company will also offer laboratory space and internal datasets that could be useful for training AI models. Kelly is enthusiastic about the potential for X-Labs, which he says have the potential to “pull platforms into existence” like the federal Human Genome Project once did, which enabled a lot of subsequent innovation.
As scientific and technology companies become more powerful, Kelly says, it’s natural that governments should revisit how to involve them in government-led science. “The scale of companies is not like it was in the Vannevar Bush era [in the 1940s],” he says, “so how should the United States leverage those [much larger, more capable] companies? It’s silly to leave them on the sidelines.” In 1945, Vannevar Bush wrote an influential report that helped shape the modern NSF and U.S. federal science funding. A July report by Michael Kratsios, director of the Office of Science and Technology Policy, offered the current administration’s vision for an update to the Bush report, including the role of X-Labs.
Arthur Daemmrich, an historian of U.S. technology policy at Arizona State University (ASU), says he welcomes the administration’s willingness to experiment with science funding. “The field had gotten very staid…this administration has a certain energy that I haven’t seen in past administrations.” He also points out that the X-Labs approach to scientific work is “like gig work for science,” so while it may work for some people and some problems, it may not work for others.
The contribution these larger projects make to society is also worth studying, says Zachary Pirtle, a former NASA program manager and now a colleague of Daemmrich’s at ASU, though it’s an open question just how to do so. “If you’re funding these amazing teams and you want them to benefit society you can’t just have engineers and scientists. Do you need to have economists on some of these teams? Or a variety of different social scientists?”
Academics Embrace X-Labs AI Model
Some academics are leaning into the X-Labs model. Nathalie Risso, an electrical engineer at the University of Arizona in Tucson, does applied research on automating mining equipment. Risso is applying under the AI for physical systems topic, aiming to test self-learning AI operation of heavy mining equipment.
“X-Labs lets us explore things that are bigger than we can do in a lab, or that we might have done in a mine, but they won’t let us use their concentrators because they cost so much,” she says. The costs of getting it right exceed a typical university grant and the cost of getting it wrong is more than any industry partner wants to risk.
These kinds of missed opportunities justify an X-Labs sized program, say supporters. A spokesperson for the Secunda Family Foundation, another X-labs consortium partner, says that AI is part of what makes the NSF’s approach so urgent. “AI and other new technologies are rapidly changing what scientists can attempt, but the infrastructure and institutions supporting research have to evolve with them.”
“Engineers should be excited about the fact that there are open and new opportunities for people with an entrepreneurial mindset,” Cimaglia says, “You don’t have to be part of a university.”
Greenberg agrees. “This is more like founding a new organization than pitching a specific research project.”
Related Articles Around the Web
原文为英文,正文由自动抓取并保留原文。
原文发布于 IEEE Spectrum AI(NSF’s X-Labs Program Draws Support From Charities and Investors),标题、摘要与正文由机器翻译,术语按行业惯例统一,未经人工逐句校订。