11-19 更新 实时
首页/ 科技公司/ 正文

NVIDIA 危机令公司治理专家坐等看戏

科技公司 来源:TechCrunch AI 2026-11-11 15:30 2 阅读 机器翻译
NVIDIA 危机令公司治理专家坐等看戏

Nvidia 股价周二下跌 5.47%,此前周一已下跌 4%,两天累计跌幅约 9.5%,而公司本身并没有传出多少消息。据报道,CEO 黄仁勋(Jensen Huang)一直试图照常开展业务,此前他承认与 Alice Huang 有婚外情——Alice Huang 曾是 Nvidia 客户 Megaspeed 的高管,美国情报机构认为她在为中国从事间谍活动。最大的进展似乎是 Nvidia 董事会聘请律师事务所 Wachtell, Lipton, Rosen & Katz 展开调查。

接下来会发生什么,基本上只能靠猜,即便是研究董事会应如何应对危机的人也是如此。两位公司治理教授——科罗拉多大学的 Ann Lipton 和芝加哥大学的 Todd Henderson——表示,对于一位卷入疑似“蜜罐”陷阱的 CEO,其实并没有真正的先例。虽然他们对调查应当追问什么有自己的看法,但和其他人一样,他们也在观望事态如何发展。

“其实过去确实有过婚外情案例和性骚扰案例,”Lipton 说,但她随即补充道,据她所知,此前并没有哪起案件同时涉及潜在的国家安全受损。Henderson 的研究领域包括公司、证券监管以及法律与经济学,他表示,这在很大程度上取决于目前鲜有人掌握的事实,其中最重要的就是:Alice Huang 从黄仁勋那里得到了什么(如果有的话)。(有关 Nvidia 晶圆厂或芯片设计的机密对司法部来说很重要。普通的公司信息大概就不重要。)

Lipton 将这项由 Nvidia 独立董事主导、并配有他们自己的外部律师的调查,形容为迄今为止整起事件中或许最“标准”的一环。她还指出,一项调查会“完全按照”主导它的董事们所希望的彻底程度来进行,而这也是标准做法。Henderson 就激励机制提出了一个相关的观点,称开展内部调查的华盛顿律所“清楚是谁在付他们的账单”。他并未暗示本案中就存在这种情况。

Lipton 说,她看到三条调查线索,包括是否触犯法律、Huang 是否违反 Nvidia 的内部政策,以及董事会是否被误导——包括他有多坦诚、以及他何时被告知相关情况。值得注意的是,正如 Wired 周一报道的那样,Huang 早在整整一年前就聘请了一家以处理性丑闻著称的公关危机公司。当然,其动因也可能仅仅与这段婚外情有关。目前尚不清楚 Huang 是何时得知 Alice Huang 被怀疑是间谍的。董事会在周日就此发表的声明中表示,Nvidia“没有理由认为国家安全或 NVIDIA 的机密受到了损害”。

Henderson 同样强调了 Huang 知道什么、以及何时知道的重要性。他描述了两种情形。一种情形是,Huang 因为婚外情令人难堪而聘请公关公司,但并不知道这名女子是谁。另一种情形是,他知道她是一名被怀疑的中国间谍。“我认为这非常不同,”他说。“如果我是董事会成员,而一家掌握非常敏感技术的公司的 CEO 处于那种境地,他们却不告诉我,我会非常愤怒。”Henderson 说,不告诉董事会你得了癌症,“或者你一直和一名中国间谍上床”,“在我看来都属于足以被解雇的过错”。

无论走哪条路,Lipton 都预计会出现股东诉讼,她说可能有两类。最显而易见的是证券欺诈诉讼,用她的话说,这类诉讼“只关乎是否撒谎”。正如我们昨日报道的那样,NVIDIA 已经面临一起拟议的集体诉讼,指控 NVIDIA 和黄仁勋将公司与 Megaspeed 的往来描述为常规业务,从而误导了投资者。“你和中国间谍有多少往来都可以,”Lipton 说,“只是根据联邦证券法,你不能对此撒谎。”

而在 NVIDIA 注册地特拉华州的法律下,提起管理不善索赔要难得多。她说,员工“一直在做愚蠢、鲁莽或有害的事情”,而法院不会因此就让股东每次都提起诉讼。股东代表公司提起此类索赔(即股东代表诉讼,derivative suit),必须首先证明董事会无力处理该问题,通常要证明董事本人牵涉其中,或对 CEO 唯命是从以至于无法独立行事。

正如《纽约时报》周二上午的一篇文章所述,NVIDIA 由 10 人组成的董事会向来有忠诚于、顺从黄仁勋的记录。尽管如此,这些“独立”董事已宣布与外部律师共同开展调查,这使得证明董事会无力处理变得非常困难。Lipton 举例提到,几年前麦当劳也曾因涉嫌管理不善而遭遇股东诉讼,起因是其首席人力官被指控骚扰,而 CEO 与一名下属存在恋爱关系。最终,法院认定没有理由认为董事会无法自行处理这一不当行为。

即便这一切最终都不会威胁到黄仁勋的职位,这一事件也引发了其他治理层面的问题,事后回看并不好看。Nvidia 以组织结构极为扁平著称,直接向黄仁勋汇报的人超过 60 位,而且公司似乎没有继任计划,利普顿称这是「对任何公司来说都是一种危险」。

黄仁勋的子女也在 Nvidia 工作。他的儿子斯宾塞是产品管理总监,女儿麦迪逊是产品营销高级总监,女婿尼科·卡普雷兹在业务发展部门工作。一些员工认为他正在培养接班人;上个月被 Bloomberg 问及麦迪逊是否会接任这一职位时,黄仁勋没有否认这种可能,只是说这不是他希望她承担的事。

利普顿称,聘用自家子女是糟糕的公司治理习惯,尽管创始人长期以来一直这么做。(她指出,金巴尔·马斯克之所以在 Tesla 董事会,是因为他是埃隆·马斯克的弟弟。)董事本应只为股东行事,但只要公司蒸蒸日上,创始人就能获得更大的宽容度。

亨德森同样自称是坚定的「反裙带关系者」,并分享说,当年他父亲在 Westinghouse 的核研究实验室工作时,那里绝对禁止雇用员工子女。「就是,他们在那里工作是可以的,」他在谈到黄仁勋的子女在 Nvidia 工作时说。但他补充说,在一家像 Nvidia 这样规模的上市公司,「他的某个孩子会接他的班」这个想法「简直疯狂」。

从治理角度来看,NVIDIA 可能做得更对的一点,恰恰是它没有的东西——双层股权结构。据报道,黄仁勋持股约 3.6%,因此他并不掌握投票控制权。利普顿表示,这让他在公司中“更容易被罢免”,尽管他在其他方面与公司深度绑定。两位教授都明确表示,他们既不支持也不反对黄仁勋。一个简单的事实是:如果投票控制权叠加在黄仁勋的持股之上,董事会的回旋余地会更小;而没有这种控制权,董事会就多了一些选择。

当您通过我们文章中的链接购买时,我们可能会赚取少量佣金。这不会影响我们编辑的独立性。

总编辑兼总经理

正在加载下一篇文章

译文由英文原文机器翻译,术语按行业惯例统一,可在文末展开原文核对。

查看英文原文(Nvidia’s crisis has corporate governance experts reaching for the popcorn)

Nvidia’s stock sank 5.47% on Tuesday, following a 4% drop on Monday, a loss of about 9.5% in two days, even though there wasn’t much news out of the company. CEO Jensen Huang has reportedly been trying to conduct business as usual after admitting an extramarital affair with Alice Huang, a former executive at Nvidia customer Megaspeed whom U.S. intelligence agencies believe was spying for China. The biggest development seemed to be that Nvidia’s board hired the law firm Wachtell, Lipton, Rosen & Katz to conduct its investigation.

What comes next is mostly a guessing game, even for the people who study how boards are supposed to handle crises. Two corporate governance professors, Ann Lipton of the University of Colorado and Todd Henderson of the University of Chicago, say there is no real precedent for a CEO caught up in a suspected honeypot. And while they have views on what the investigation should ask, like everyone else, they’re watching to see how it plays out.

“There have actually been affair cases and sexual harassment cases,” Lipton said, but was quick to add that she doesn’t know of previous cases that also involve potential national security compromises. Henderson, whose research interests include corporations, securities regulation, and law and economics, said much depends on facts few people have yet, including, most importantly, what, if anything, Alice Huang got out of Jensen Huang. (Secrets about Nvidia’s fabs or chip designs would matter to the Justice Department. Ordinary corporate information probably would not.)

Lipton described the investigation led by Nvidia’s independent board members, with their own outside counsel, as perhaps the most “standard” aspect of the whole affair so far. She also observed that an investigation will be “exactly as thorough” as the directors running it want it to be, which is also standard. Henderson made a related point about incentives, saying that Washington law firms that conduct internal investigations “know who pays their bills.” He didn’t suggest that is happening here.

Lipton said she sees three lines of inquiry, including whether the law was broken, whether Huang violated Nvidia’s internal policies, and whether the board was misled, including how forthcoming he was and when he was on notice. It’s notable, as Wired reported Monday, that Huang hired a PR crisis firm known for handling sex scandals a full year ago. Of course, the driver could have been about the affair alone. It’s unclear when Huang learned Alice Huang was a suspected spy. The board said in a Sunday statement about the matter that Nvidia has “has no reason to believe that either national security or NVIDIA secrets were compromised.”

Henderson similarly stressed the importance of what Huang knew and when. He described two scenarios. In one, Huang hires a PR firm because an extramarital affair is embarrassing, without knowing who the woman is. In the other, he knows she is a suspected Chinese spy. “I think that’s very different,” he said. “If I were a board member and the CEO of a company with very sensitive technology was in that situation, I would be furious if they didn’t tell me.” Not telling the board that you have cancer “or that you’ve been sleeping with a Chinese spy,” said Henderson, “seems to me to be a fireable offense.”

Either way, Lipton expects shareholder suits, and she said two kinds are possible. Securities fraud, which she said is “only about lying,” is the most obvious, and as we reported yesterday, Nvidia is already facing a proposed class action lawsuit that alleges Nvidia and Huang misled investors by describing the company’s Megaspeed dealings as routine. “You can have as many affairs with Chinese spies as you like,” Lipton said. “You just can’t lie about it under the federal securities laws.”

A mismanagement claim under Delaware law, where Nvidia is incorporated, is much harder. Employees do “stupid or reckless or damaging things all the time,” she said, and courts don’t let shareholders sue each time. Shareholders bringing such a claim on the company’s behalf, known as a derivative suit, must first show the board is incapable of handling the problem, usually by proving directors are implicated or so beholden to the CEO that they can’t act independently.

Nvidia’s 10-member board has a track record of loyalty and deference to Huang, as outlined by a New York Times piece Tuesday morning. Still, the investigation those “independent” directors have announced with outside counsel makes that very hard. Lipton cited, for example, a shareholder suit over alleged mismanagement at McDonald’s several years ago, after its chief people officer was accused of harassment and its CEO had a relationship with a subordinate. Ultimately, the court found no reason the board couldn’t deal with the misconduct on its own.

Even if none of this ends up threatening Huang’s job, the episode raises other governance questions that don’t look great in retrospect. Nvidia is run with a famously flat structure, with more than 60 direct reports to Huang, and the company doesn’t appear to have a succession plan, which Lipton called “a danger for any company.”

Huang’s children also work at Nvidia. His son Spencer is a director of product management, his daughter Madison is a senior director of product marketing, and his son-in-law, Nico Caprez, works in business development. Some employees believe he is grooming successors, and asked last month by Bloomberg whether Madison is in line for the job, Huang didn’t shoot down the idea, saying instead that it’s not something he’d wish on her.

Lipton called hiring the kids poor corporate hygiene, even though founders have long done it. (Kimbal Musk is on Tesla’s board because he’s Elon Musk’s brother, she noted.) Directors are supposed to act only for stockholders, but founders get more rope as long as the company is thriving.

Henderson similarly calls himself a strong “anti-nepotism person,” sharing that when his father worked at Westinghouse’s nuclear research lab, there was an absolute ban on hiring employees’ children. “Like, fine for them to be working there,” he said of Huang’s children working at Nvidia. But “the idea that one of his kids would succeed him” at a publicly traded company the size of Nvidia “seems crazy,” he added.

What Nvidia may have gotten more right, from a governance standpoint, is what it doesn’t have, which is dual-class shares. Huang reportedly owns about 3.6%, so he doesn’t control the vote. That makes him “easier to dislodge,” Lipton said, even though he is deeply integrated into the company in other ways. Neither professor is rooting for or against Huang, each made clear. The simple truth is that with voting control on top of Huang’s holdings, the board would have even less flexibility. Without it, the board has a few more options.

When you purchase through links in our articles, we may earn a small commission. This doesn’t affect our editorial independence.

Connie Loizos

Editor in Chief & General Manager

Loizos has been reporting on Silicon Valley since the late ’90s, when she joined the original Red Herring magazine. Previously the Silicon Valley Editor of TechCrunch, she was named Editor in Chief and General Manager of TechCrunch in September 2023. She’s also the founder of StrictlyVC, a daily e-newsletter and lecture series acquired by Yahoo in August 2023 and now operated as a sub brand of TechCrunch.

You can contact or verify outreach from Connie by emailing [email protected] or [email protected], or via encrypted message at ConnieLoizos.53 on Signal.

Loading the next article

原文为英文,正文由自动抓取并保留原文。

本文由采集器自动同步

原文发布于 TechCrunch AI(Nvidia’s crisis has corporate governance experts reaching for the popcorn),标题、摘要与正文由机器翻译,术语按行业惯例统一,未经人工逐句校订。

阅读原文 ↗