11-19 更新 实时
首页/ 科技公司/ 正文

英国政府网站安全漏洞暴露“神级”信息

科技公司 来源:Wired 2026-11-10 15:00 0 阅读 机器翻译
英国政府网站安全漏洞暴露“神级”信息

一名安全研究员在英国公开的政府代码中发现了 100 多个严重漏洞,由于网络安全卫生状况不佳,敏感数据因此面临风险。

大约十年来,英国政府一直默认公开用公共资金产出的代码,因为这具有透明度,而且让代码更容易被复用也更节省成本。这包括卫生与社会保障部、内政部以及地方当局。

但资金紧张使各部门忽视了对自身技术资产的维护和改进。ControlPlane 安全研究员 Chris Nesbitt-Smith 使用 Claude 的 Opus 和 Sonnet AI 模型发现了这些漏洞,不过他表示,自己是在笔记本电脑上使用消费级模型,而且许多问题本可以通过例行的 IT 健康检查发现。“这些都不是普通媒体在网络安全攻击方面所担忧的那种复杂程度,”他告诉 WIRED。“全是些愚蠢的东西。”

在他发现的最严重案例中,负责英格兰各地土地使用事务的规划督查署(Planning Inspectorate)曾不小心将登录凭证提交到公共代码仓库 GitHub,之后又未能将其彻底删除。这些凭证拥有如此广泛的访问权限——而且似乎不会过期——再加上该机构意外将其公开,“使得对他们来说尤其危险”。

据 Nesbitt-Smith 称,完整的 Microsoft Entra ID 本可对全部 SharePoint 站点和员工私人的 OneDrive 账户获得“神级”读写权限,其中包括人力资源档案。这位发现该漏洞的安全研究员表示,它还能访问若干敏感资料库,这些资料库用于在法定规划调查与上诉期间依法保全证据。“对他们实施勒索软件攻击、加密全部数据,或者干脆把数据全部窃走,这些选项都充分具备,”Nesbitt-Smith 说。

规划监察局(Planning Inspectorate)的一位发言人告诉 WIRED,其网络监控工具在 8 月就立即检测到了 Nesbitt-Smith 的活动,并且在 ControlPlane 联系他们之前,该局已将其作为网络安全事件处理。该机构在接到报告后 20 分钟内就识别并修复了这一漏洞,并确认未发生数据泄露。“我们已审查并加强了系统与流程,以防止此类问题再次发生,我们感谢这位研究员的工作,也感谢他向我们发出提醒,”他们告诉 WIRED。

非营利行业组织 OpenUK 的首席执行官 Amanda Brock 表示,规划监察局的这件事“不是开源问题,而是使用公共工具时的内部管理问题”。“那些数据之所以暴露,是因为未能遵循良好流程,”她补充说。“这不是开源安全问题。”

Nesbitt-Smith 扫描了 33 个组织的 349 个公共部门代码库,他说其中约三分之二存在漏洞。其中若干漏洞出现在教育部的代码中,包括学校使用的一项采购服务、一个包含个人详细信息、学历、工作经历和身份证明文件的教师申请服务,以及英格兰政府资助的培训机构与学徒制项目的主要登记系统。他还在苏格兰政府的一个开放数据门户中发现了一处漏洞,该漏洞本可让任何访客读取管理账户信息并更改网站配置。相关机构此后已处理了这些问题。

近来出现了一些主张,认为既然 AI 加速了漏洞发现,公共部门就应停止公开发布源代码。据报道,出于对 AI 模型影响的安全担忧,NHS 在 5 月下令技术团队逐步弃用开源代码。

在 Nesbitt-Smith 看来,这样做却不立即修复底层问题,将是“最糟糕的情况”,因为这会阻止像他这样的研究人员发现漏洞,而对手很可能早已镜像了这些代码库,因而仍能持续访问它们。Nesbitt-Smith 说:“除非你打算把全部问题都修好,否则关闭它反倒可能引来更多关注,因为你的意思就像是,‘这片区域里有龙,但请你们别看这里。’”

爱彼迎房东们怒不可遏:他们再也不能让房客做家务了

重磅报道:酷小孩打字全用小写——这让你生气吗?

译文由英文原文机器翻译,术语按行业惯例统一,可在文末展开原文核对。

查看英文原文(Security Flaws Across UK Government Sites Exposed ‘God-Tier’ Information)

A security researcher has found more than 100 serious vulnerabilities in publicly available UK government code, putting sensitive data at risk as a result of poor cyber hygiene.

The UK government has defaulted to openly publishing code it produces with public money for around a decade because it’s transparent, and making it easier for code to be reused is cost-efficient. This includes within the Department of Health and Social Care, and the Home Office, as well as local authorities.

But funding squeezes have left departments neglecting maintenance and improvement of their technology estate. While ControlPlane security researcher Chris Nesbitt-Smith found the vulnerabilities using Claude’s Opus and Sonnet AI models, he says that he used consumer-grade models on a laptop and that many of the issues could have been caught by a routine IT health check. “None of this is the level of sophistication that general media is worried about in terms of cyber attacks,” he tells WIRED. “It’s all daft stuff.”

In the most serious case he identified, the Planning Inspectorate, which handles land-use matters across England, had failed to fully remove a login after it accidentally committed them to public repository GitHub. The fact the credentials gave such wide access—and seemingly didn’t expire—compounded with the agency’s accidental publication of them, “made it particularly dangerous for them.”

The complete Microsoft Entra ID would have given “god-tier” read and write access to all SharePoint sites and private employee OneDrive accounts, according to Nesbitt-Smith, including HR records. It also would have given access to sensitive libraries which safeguard evidence under legal hold for statutory planning inquiries and appeals, according to the security researcher who found it. “The option for ransomwaring them, for encrypting all the data, or just stealing all the data, was abundantly there,” Nesbitt-Smith says.

A spokesperson for the Planning Inspectorate told WIRED its cyber monitoring tools immediately detected Nesbitt-Smith’s activity in August and that it had already been handling this as a cyber incident when ControlPlane made contact. The agency identified and fixed this vulnerability within 20 minutes of the report and verified that no data breach occurred. “We have reviewed and strengthened our systems and processes to prevent this type of issue recurring and we are grateful for the researcher’s work and for alerting us to it,” they told WIRED.

The Planning Inspectorate issue “isn’t about open source but internal housekeeping when using public tools,” Amanda Brock, chief executive officer of nonprofit industry group OpenUK. “That data was exposed because of a failure not to follow good process,” she adds. “That’s not an open source security issue.”

In around two-thirds of the 349 public sector codebases across 33 organizations Nesbitt-Smith scanned, he said he found vulnerabilities. Several of these were found in the Department of Education’s code, including in a procurement service used by schools, in a teacher application service containing personal details, qualifications, employment history and identity documents, and England’s main register of government-funded training providers and apprenticeships. He also found a vulnerability in a Scottish Government open data portal which would have allowed any visitor to read administrative account information and to change site configuration. The organizations have since dealt with the issues.

Recently, there have been arguments for public sector departments to stop publishing source code in the open, now that AI has accelerated vulnerability discovery. The NHS reportedly ordered technology teams to transition away from open source code in May amid security concerns about the impact of AI models.

Doing this without immediately fixing the underlying issues would be the “worst case scenario,” according to Nesbitt-Smith, as it prevents researchers like him from finding them, and it’s likely that an adversary has already mirrored these repositories and so will maintain access to them. “Unless you’re going to go and fix all of the problems, if anything, you’re probably drawing more attention to it by closing it,” says Nesbitt-Smith, “because you’re like, ‘Here be dragons over this space. Don’t look here though, please.’”

Airbnb hosts are furious they can no longer make guests do their chores

big story: cool kids write in all lowercase—does that make you mad?

原文为英文,正文由自动抓取并保留原文。

本文由采集器自动同步

原文发布于 Wired(Security Flaws Across UK Government Sites Exposed ‘God-Tier’ Information),标题、摘要与正文由机器翻译,术语按行业惯例统一,未经人工逐句校订。

阅读原文 ↗