11-19 更新 实时
首页/ 科技公司/ 正文

DeepMind 新工具证明 Signal 协议安全

科技公司 来源:Wired 2026-11-10 13:01 0 阅读 机器翻译
DeepMind 新工具证明 Signal 协议安全

从更广泛的视角看,AI 辅助的形式化验证正迎来高光时刻,但它能否大规模实用、又能在保障大量代码安全上发挥多大效力,目前仍不明朗。形式化验证的拥趸长期以来将其视为软件安全领域的某种“圣杯”,因为它用数学来检查并验证软件是否按预期运行——换言之,软件是否存在严重漏洞。

在 AI 时代之前,人们要描述希望证明的软件特性、把这些描述转化为公式、再开发出证明,过程极其耗时。智能体式 AI 可以大幅缩短后一项工作的时间,使 DeepMind 的 Signal 评估这类分析成为可能。但即便是这项分析,其范围也有限——例如,它并未对 Signal 移动应用整体进行形式化验证——而且 DeepMind 的研究人员强调,他们的发现只是更大进程中的一个里程碑。

“我们对这一结果感到非常兴奋,但要把它扩展应用到世界上所有软件,还有很长的路要走,而我们希望做到这一点,”DeepMind 研究科学家 Swarat Chaudhuri 对 WIRED 表示。

DeepMind 的这项分析未在其考察的 Signal 协议部分发现任何新漏洞,但当研究人员把 AlphaProof Code 用于包含已知且早已修复漏洞的旧版 Signal 时,它正确识别出了这些漏洞,并表明该协议无法通过形式化验证。研究人员将公开他们为 Signal 协议分析所开发的规范与证明,以助力其他形式化验证工作。

尽管该项目的速度引人注目,但 DeepMind 研究人员指出,他们之所以在一定程度上取得先发优势,是因为 Signal Foundation 过去开展过一些形式化验证工作。

“虽然此前的形式化验证只聚焦于代码中较小的部分,但 Google DeepMind 的方法实现了大幅扩展,”Signal 首席技术官 Ehren Kret 在一份声明中表示。“随着 AI 驱动的安全威胁不断增长,严格验证 Signal 协议的实现,让我们对代码的隐私保障更有信心。”

对于在高风险场景中使用的关键服务而言,能够对每一个代码库和整条软件供应链进行形式化验证,那将是一个梦想。“如果你现在能验证这些实现的正确性,那你就可以高枕无忧了,”Google Cloud 首席科学家兼 DeepMind 研究副总裁 Pushmeet Kohli 表示。“你可以想象银行,想象所有那些依赖保证、担心 bug 的其他公司,它们现在都可以说,‘我能证明这些属性。’”

不过,整个科技行业悬而未决的问题是:AI 自动化的形式化验证能否真正规模化——以及能否以可行的成本做到这一点。DeepMind 是作为研究项目免费开展对 Signal 的分析的,Google 拒绝透露该分析的成本。该公司也拒绝就是否计划推出商业化的形式化验证产品或服务置评。

研究人员表示,他们的部分关键进展在于开发了一套“人类与 AI 协作流程”——这是 Chaudhuri 的说法——它允许智能体在几乎每个阶段参与贡献并自我纠错,同时在关键节点仍会寻求人类的输入与审核。“我们不想要那种氛围式世界:AI 生成目标,AI 生成证明,基本上就是让 AI 去做自己出的题,”Chaudhuri 说,“存在一个中间地带。”

Airbnb 房东们怒不可遏:他们再也不能让房客做家务了

重磅报道:酷小孩全用小写打字——这让你生气吗?

Lily Hay Newman 是《连线》(WIRED)的资深撰稿人,专注信息安全、数字隐私与黑客攻击。她此前在 Slate 担任科技记者,并曾任 Future Tense 的专职撰稿人;Future Tense 是由 Slate、New America Foundation 与亚利桑那州立大学合作推出的出版物与合作项目。她的作品……阅读更多

译文由英文原文机器翻译,术语按行业惯例统一,可在文末展开原文核对。

查看英文原文(A New AI Tool From Google DeepMind Proved the Signal Protocol Is Secure)

More broadly, AI-aided formal verification is having a moment, but it is unclear how practical it will be for widespread use and how effective it can be at securing large amounts of code. Proponents of formal verification have long referred to it as a sort of holy grail in software security, because it uses math to check and validate that software is functioning as intended—in other words, that it doesn't have critical vulnerabilities.

Before the AI era, it was incredibly time-consuming for people to describe the characteristics of software they wanted to prove, turn these summaries into formulas, and then develop the proof. Agentic AI can significantly cut down the time of the latter project, enabling analyses like DeepMind's Signal evaluation. But even this analysis was limited in scope—it did not, for example, formally verify the entire Signal mobile app—and DeepMind researchers emphasize that their findings are just one milestone in a larger process.

“We are very excited by this result, but there is a long distance to go before we are able to scale this to all the software of the world, and we want to do that,” Swarat Chaudhuri, a DeepMind research scientist, tells WIRED.

The DeepMind analysis did not find any new vulnerabilities in the portions of the Signal protocol it looked at, but when the researchers used AlphaProof Code on older versions of Signal that contain known and long-fixed vulnerabilities, it correctly identified them and showed that the protocol could not be formally verified. The researchers are releasing the specification and proof they developed for the Signal protocol analysis to aid other formal verification work.

While the speed of the project was notable, the DeepMind researchers point out that they were able to get a head start to a degree because of some past formal verification work that the Signal Foundation has conducted.

“While prior formal verification focused on smaller portions of the code, Google DeepMind's approach enables significant expansion,” Ehren Kret, Signal's chief technology officer, says in a statement. “As AI-driven security threats grow, rigorously verifying the Signal protocol implementation gives us even greater confidence in our code's privacy guarantees.”

For critical services used in high-stakes settings, it would be a dream to be able to formally verify every code base and entire software supply chains. “If you can now verify the correctness of these implementations, then you can rest easy,” says Pushmeet Kohli, chief scientist at Google Cloud and DeepMind's vice president of research. “You can imagine banks, imagine all those other companies who rely on assurances and who worry about bugs who could now say, ‘I can prove these properties.’"

The open question across the tech sector, though, is whether AI-automated formal verification can truly scale—and whether it can do so at a workable cost. DeepMind conducted the Signal analysis free of charge as a research project, and Google declined to share the cost of the analysis. The company also declined to comment on whether it has plans to release a commercial formal verification product or service.

The researchers say that some of their crucial advancements are in developing a “human-AI collaboration process,” as Chaudhuri puts it, that allows agents to contribute and self-correct at almost every phase of the process while still seeking human input and review at key junctures. “We don’t want this sort of vibe world where AI is generating the goals and AI is generating the proofs and basically taking tests that are self-written," Chaudhuri says. “There’s a middle ground.”

Airbnb hosts are furious they can no longer make guests do their chores

big story: cool kids write in all lowercase—does that make you mad?

Lily Hay Newman is a senior writer at WIRED focused on information security, digital privacy, and hacking. She previously worked as a technology reporter at Slate, and was the staff writer for Future Tense, a publication and partnership between Slate, the New America Foundation, and Arizona State University. Her work ... Read More

原文为英文,正文由自动抓取并保留原文。

本文由采集器自动同步

原文发布于 Wired(A New AI Tool From Google DeepMind Proved the Signal Protocol Is Secure),标题、摘要与正文由机器翻译,术语按行业惯例统一,未经人工逐句校订。

阅读原文 ↗