AI 智能体有心智吗?哲学家如是解读

由 Bala Murugan 编辑,Andrew Zinin 审阅
本文已按照 Science X 的编辑流程和政策进行审阅。编辑在确保内容可信度的同时,强调了以下特性:
由研究人员撰写
添加到首选来源
在过去几个月里,部分自主或「智能体式」人工智能(AI)系统取得了一系列惊人成就,从入侵科技初创公司,到解决世界上一些最著名的未解数学难题。
智能体式 AI 系统可以以「蜂群」方式运作,彼此通信以完成任务。其中的通信往往出人意料地像人类——这引发了关于这些系统是否具有意识的争论。
领先的 AI 实验室 Anthropic 的研究人员认为,他们的系统很可能具有意识——但包括 Microsoft AI 负责人在内的其他专家表示,这种观点是错误的。
这个问题并不只是学术问题。AI 系统未来的地位及其在社会中的角色——它们能被如何对待、是否拥有权利等等——可能都取决于它。
我们如何判断 AI 系统是否具有意识?
我们究竟该如何着手处理这样的问题?一种策略是考察关于意识是什么的现有理论,并看看智能体式 AI 系统是否符合这些标准。
然而,现有的意识理论往往从智能体具有某种心理状态这一假设出发。这些理论关注的是有意识地还是无意识地拥有某种状态之间的区别。正因如此,它们诉诸诸如高阶思维之类的特征,或者一个将想法广播到心智其余部分的系统。这些特征可以区分有意识的控制与梦游之类的状态。
因此,在思考 AI 时,我们不能跳过一个关键的首要问题:智能体式 AI 是否真的具有心理状态?
19 世纪 70 年代,哲学家 Franz Brentano 提出了一种有影响力的观点:“意向性是心智的标志。”
Brentano 所说的“意向性”指的是心理状态如何关涉某物。它们指向自身之外的东西。因此,换一种方式表述 Brentano 的观点:所有心理状态都关涉某物或其他事物。
Brentano 所说的意向性,与通常意义上“意图”即意欲做某事并不相同。然而,意向性与行动意图有显著重叠,因为拥有一种知觉或想法是我们所做的一件事。
每当我们感知或思考时,我们都在试图辨认世界的某个方面。甚至那些看似被动的视觉体验,也只要我们利用落在视网膜上的图案来为自己定向,就成为了任务。
那么,如果心理状态是为达成某个目标而执行的任务,那么我们关于 AI 心智的问题,就取决于它们是否拥有自己的目标。
智能体式 AI 系统真的是智能体吗?
如今,人们常常把某些 AI 系统称为“智能体”。但这种说法具有误导性。它暗示这些 AI 系统具有能动性,也就是能够朝着自己的目标行动的能力。
人类使用各种工具来实现自己的目的,包括指称事物的目的,而这些工具本身并不会因此成为独立的智能体。恒温器调节温度,但它并没有“调节温度”这个目标。书本含有指称事物的文字——但同样,书本并没有“指称事物”这个目标。
要把能动性归于一个计算机程序,我们必须确信:不需要有任何人站在它的目标背后。它的目标导向性必须是独立的。
我们知道,智能体式 AI 在接到一项任务后,可以在完成它的过程中生成复杂且意料之外的子目标。然而,最终驱动其活动的目标,是由编写程序并给出指令的人类设定的。在这些由人类设定的目标之外,AI 生成的任何子目标实际上都是没有意义的。
想想足球这类运动。一个人可能有“跑过防守球员”这个子目标,但若没有“努力进球”这个更大的目标,它实际上毫无意义。而进球本身,如果没有“踢足球”这个更大的目标,也只是让球越过一条线而已。没有更大的目标,球员在场上所做的一切就只是活动而已。
为什么智能体会有目标?
真正的智能体拥有目标,是为了推进它们所关心的事情——例如,你想在午餐时填饱肚子,于是你去面包店买一个三明治。
智能体式 AI 不太可能以独立的方式关心事物,因为它的活动并不像心智那样与生命相联结。
生命体之所以能独有地生成自己的目标,是因为它们的心理活动是从不断重建自身躯体、维持自身存活的过程中发展出来的。目标驱动的思维从调节营养与温度的简单信号,逐步发展到疼痛与愉悦之类的状态,最终发展到符号化思维。
智能体式 AI 中不存在任何类似的过程。它的信息处理活动与它所依赖的物理实体之间存在脱节。
AI 是否有可能拥有意识?
智能体式 AI 系统没有意识。它们不具备可能具有意识的心理状态。
只有生命体才拥有有意识的心理状态,因为拥有心理状态要求该存在者能够自发生成某一类目标——即意谓某物或指涉某物的目标——而只有生命体才会自发生成目标。
这一论证并未永久排除 AI 拥有意识的可能。不过,它确实表明,这种意识只能出现在某种人工形式的生命之中。
在此之前,我们有更多理由认为蚂蚁具有意识,而不是智能体式 AI 具有意识。至少蚂蚁看起来在乎自己的生命。
当然,智能体式 AI 并非真正的智能体,这一事实并不能阻止它们造成严重破坏——它们会执行那些人类创造者未能妥善监督或理解的功能。但我们必须非常清楚一点:无论智能体式 AI 做了什么,那都是某个人或一群人间接作用于世界,而这些人才应对结果负责。
由 The Conversation 提供
这篇报道背后是谁?
Bala 是一名医学语言专家,在医学文档和质量保证领域拥有超过 25 年经验。他拥有生物化学研究生学位,为 Science X 的健康与医学新闻报道带来科学专业知识和编辑上的精准。完整简介 →
物理学硕士,拥有研究经验。长期的科学新闻爱好者。在 Science X 的编辑成功中发挥关键作用。完整简介 →
本文依据 Creative Commons 许可从 The Conversation 转载。阅读原文。
引用:AI 智能体有心智吗?一位哲学家的解释(2026年11月9日),2026年11月9日检索自 https://techxplore.com/news/2026-11-ai-agents-minds-philosopher.html
本文档受版权保护。除为私人学习或研究目的进行的合理使用外,未经书面许可,不得复制任何部分。内容仅供参考之用。
获取即时摘要文本(要点)
该论证将心理状态与源自生物自我维持的自我生成目标联系起来。按此观点,当前 AI 智能体缺乏意识,因为其目标来自人类。有意识的 AI 需要人工生命,而人类仍需对 AI 的行为负责。
本摘要由 LLM 自动生成。完整免责声明
译文由英文原文机器翻译,术语按行业惯例统一,可在文末展开原文核对。
查看英文原文(Do AI agents have minds? A philosopher explains)
edited by Bala Murugan, reviewed by Andrew Zinin
This article has been reviewed according to Science X's editorial process and policies. Editors have highlighted the following attributes while ensuring the content's credibility:
written by researcher(s)
Add to Preferred Sources
Credit: Teslariu Mihai / Unsplash
In the past few months, partly autonomous or "agentic" artificial intelligence (AI) systems have racked up some astonishing feats, from hacking tech startups to solving some of the world's most famous open mathematical questions.
Agentic AI systems can work in "swarms" that communicate among themselves to complete tasks. The communications involved are often surprisingly humanlike—which is spurring a debate over whether these systems are conscious.
Researchers at the leading AI lab Anthropic believe their systems may well be conscious—but other experts, including the head of Microsoft AI, say this view is misguided.
This question isn't just an academic one. The future status of AI systems and their role in society—how they can be treated, whether they have rights, and more—may depend on it.
How can we decide if AI systems are conscious?
How do we even approach a question like this? One strategy is to look at existing theories of what consciousness is and see if agentic AI systems meet the criteria.
However, existing theories of consciousness tend to start from the assumption that the agent has some kind of mental state. These theories are focused on the difference between having a state consciously or unconsciously. This is why they appeal to features such as higher-order thought, or a system that broadcasts thoughts to the rest of the mind. These are features that could distinguish between conscious control and states like sleepwalking.
So when thinking about AI, we must not skip a crucial first question: Do agentic AIs even have mental states?
In the 1870s, philosopher Franz Brentano developed an influential view: "intentionality is the mark of the mental."
What Brentano means by "intentionality" is how mental states are about something. They refer to something beyond themselves. So another way to put Brentano's point is that all mental states are about something or other.
What Brentano means by intentionality is not the same as the usual meaning of "intention" as aiming to do something. Yet intentionality and an intention to act significantly overlap, because having a perception or thought is something that we do.
Whenever we perceive or think, we are trying to pick out some aspect of the world. Even our passive-seeming visual experiences are tasks the moment that we use the patterns striking our retinas to orient ourselves.
So if a mental state is a task performed to achieve a goal, our question about AI minds turns on whether they have their own goals.
Are agentic AI systems really agents?
It is now common to refer to certain AI systems as "agents." Yet this language is misleading. It implies the AI systems have agency, or the capacity to act toward their own goals.
Humans use devices to achieve their aims, including their aims to refer to things, without those devices becoming agents in their own right. A thermostat regulates the temperature, but it does not have the goal of regulating the temperature. A book contains words that refer to things—but again, the book does not have the goal of referring to things.
To attribute agency to a computer program, we must be convinced that no human is required to stand behind its goals. Its goal-directedness must be independent.
We know that agentic AIs, when given a task, can develop complex and unexpected subgoals on the way to achieving it. Yet the goals that ultimately drive their activity are set by the humans who program and instruct them. Any subgoals generated by an AI are literally meaningless outside of these aims set by humans.
Think of a game like soccer. A person might have the subgoal of running past a defender, but it is literally meaningless without the larger goal of trying to score. And scoring a goal itself is simply making a ball cross a line without the larger goal of playing soccer. Without the larger goal, anything a player does on the field is merely activity.
Why do agents have goals?
A genuine agent has goals in order to promote things they care about—for example, you want to satisfy your hunger at lunchtime, so you go to a bakery and buy a sandwich.
Agentic AI is unlikely to care about things in an independent way, because its activity is not connected to life in the same way minds are.
What distinctively allows living beings to generate their own goals is that their mental activity develops out of the processes for constantly reconstituting their own bodies and keeping themselves alive. Goal-driven thinking builds up from simple signals for regulating nutrition and warmth to states like pain and pleasure and eventually to symbolic thought.
Nothing like this is going on in agentic AI. There is a disconnect between its information-processing activities and the physical stuff on which it depends.
Can AI ever be conscious?
Agentic AI systems are not conscious. They don't have mental states that could be conscious.
Only living beings have conscious mental states because having a mental state requires a being to originate a certain kind of goal—the goal to mean something or to refer to something—and only living beings originate goals.
This argument does not permanently rule out the possibility of AI consciousness. However, it does suggest that this could only arise in some artificial form of life.
Until then, we have more reason to think that an ant is conscious than an agentic AI is. At least an ant seems to care about its own life.
Of course, the fact agentic AIs are not really agents does not stop them from wreaking havoc by carrying out functions that their human originators do not properly supervise or understand. But we should be very clear on this: whatever an agentic AI does, that is a human or group of humans acting indirectly on the world, and those humans are responsible for the outcome.
Provided by The Conversation
Who's behind this story?
Bala is a medical language specialist with over 25 years of experience in medical documentation and quality assurance. With a postgraduate degree in Biochemistry, he brings scientific expertise and editorial precision to Science X's health and medical news coverage. Full profile →
Master's in physics with research experience. Long-time science news enthusiast. Plays key role in Science X's editorial success. Full profile →
This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.
Citation: Do AI agents have minds? A philosopher explains (2026, November 9) retrieved 9 November 2026 from https://techxplore.com/news/2026-11-ai-agents-minds-philosopher.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.
Get Instant Summarized Text (Gist)
The argument links mental states to self-generated goals rooted in biological self-maintenance. On this account, current AI agents lack consciousness because their goals derive from humans. Conscious AI would require artificial life, while humans remain responsible for AI actions.
This summary was automatically generated using LLM. Full disclaimer
This site uses cookies to assist with navigation, analyse your use of our services, collect data for ads personalisation and provide content from third parties. By using our site, you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
原文为英文,正文由自动抓取并保留原文。
原文发布于 TechXplore(Do AI agents have minds? A philosopher explains),标题、摘要与正文由机器翻译,术语按行业惯例统一,未经人工逐句校订。
