因 AI 遭抨击,有效利他主义想自己发声

本文已按照 Science X 的编辑流程与政策进行审核。编辑在确保内容可信度的同时,重点标注了以下特征:
添加到首选来源
Anthropic 首席执行官 Dario Amodei 被视为有效利他主义早期阶段的关键人物,尽管他如今否认与之存在任何关联。
有效利他主义运动与 AI 界以及引领人工智能热潮的那些公司关系密切,如今已引起主流关注,同时也招致了类似邪教行为和危言耸听的指责。
这一难以定义的运动仍在发展壮大,并希望在特朗普政府以及硅谷一些权势人物的激烈批评声中,更好地阐释自身的价值观。
其创立原则是尽可能有效地将金钱或时间投入到重大事业中,这是一种刻意保持冷静理性的做法,有时也被批评为脱离现实。
《纽约邮报》称其为“古怪的邪教”,保守派媒体《每日来电者》将其冠以“AI 末日卡特尔”之名,而一份白宫备忘录则指责它宁可拯救“虾也不愿拯救家庭”。
有效利他主义(EA)曾一度在科技界以及部分学术和政治圈之外鲜为人知,但在近期一系列关于 AI 风险的警告之后,它已成为舆论关注的焦点。
这些警告与EA(有效利他主义)有关。风险投资人、美国总统Donald Trump的顾问David Sacks认为,与EA有关联的组织属于一个推动更严格AI监管的“末日产业复合体”(Doomer Industrial Complex)。
EA深深植根于硅谷,并将控制AI的危险列为优先事项之一。
Anthropic首席执行官Dario Amodei被认为是EA早期的关键人物,尽管他如今与该运动保持距离。
Anthropic总裁Daniela Amodei是Dario的妹妹,她嫁给了Holden Karnofsky,后者是Anthropic员工,也是EA的主要倡导者。
该运动还影响了其他AI公司的研究人员和员工,包括ChatGPT的开发商OpenAI,尤其是那些从事AI安全工作的员工。
这场运动大约在15年前成形,如今已习惯了批评。
富有的EA捐赠者常常被指责自视甚高,并认为只有他们自己知道如何最好地捐赠。
“我们的想法恰恰足够奇特,以至于人们有时会真正误解它们,而我们可以更好地解释有效利他主义如何应对棘手问题和权衡取舍,”有效利他主义中心负责人Zachary Robinson说。
Robinson 所在的组织支持这场运动,但并未对其加以主导。在他看来,入夏以来受到的审视是一个敞开大门、而非退缩的机会,因为“人们现在很好奇,想了解我们”。
在 2022 年之前,EA 一直稳步发展,但加密货币平台 FTX 及其创始人 Sam Bankman-Fried 的崩塌令其遭受重创——此人曾是 EA 的门面人物,后来被判欺诈罪。
经历了几年的艰难之后,“我们现在正处于上升期,”Robinson 说,并指出 10 月中旬在纽约举行的 EA Global 大会的参会情况可以说明这一点。
与 EA Global 上的许多人一样,在加拿大一家非营利组织工作的 Shanil Wijesinghe 不接受 EA 是铁板一块的整体这一印象。“它是一场以价值观为基础的运动,而不是一场以身份认同为基础的运动,”他说。
“我们都在用自己拥有的资源,努力做最多的善事,”他说。这些价值观“可以有不同的解读,我认为我们必须拥抱这些差异”。
EA 没有领导者,也没有发言人。慈善平台 Giving What We Can 负责人 Sjir Hoeijmakers 说,这是件好事,尽管这意味着“有时候故事不会被讲出来”。
不过,他说,“有效利他主义如今已经是一场足够庞大的运动,确实在真正影响世界,也因此正受到关注”。
“我认为他们所做的工作相当有价值,”同样出席 EA Global 的遗传学研究员 Nadav Brandes 说,他指的是 AI 安全方面的工作。
“如果没有那些先驱……今天就不会还有人严肃对待这个问题了,”他补充道。
Brandes 表示,当 AI 成为 EA 的一个重要议题、与气候变化和动物福利并列时,他起初持怀疑态度。
“这甚至让我有点反感,”他回忆道。“我在这件事上完全错了。”
不过 Robinson 强调,EA 所关注的远不止 AI。
“目前最受重视的议题是 AI 安全,但我认为说 EA 就是 AI 安全是不对的,”他说。
“如果从资金层面来看,实际上多年来全球健康与发展领域获得的资金都远多于 AI,”他说。
这篇报道的幕后是谁?
物理学硕士,具备科研经验。资深科学新闻爱好者。在 Science X 的编辑工作中发挥关键作用。完整简介 →
引用来源:因 AI 问题受到抨击,有效利他主义希望讲述自己的故事(2026 年 11 月 9 日),2026 年 11 月 9 日检索自 https://techxplore.com/news/2026-11-ai-effective-altruism-story.html
本文受版权保护。除为私人学习或研究目的进行的任何合理使用外,未经书面许可,不得复制本文任何部分。内容仅供参考之用。
获取即时摘要文本(要点)
有效利他主义主张将金钱和时间分配到能最大化整体收益的事业上,包括全球健康、动物福利和 AI 安全。其与 AI 的关联招致批评和审视,促使其努力澄清自身价值观。在该运动内部,全球健康与发展获得的资金多于 AI 安全。
本摘要由 LLM 自动生成。完整免责声明
译文由英文原文机器翻译,术语按行业惯例统一,可在文末展开原文核对。
查看英文原文(Under fire over AI, effective altruism wants to tell its own story)
This article has been reviewed according to Science X's editorial process and policies. Editors have highlighted the following attributes while ensuring the content's credibility:
Add to Preferred Sources
Anthropic chief executive Dario Amodei is considered a key figure in effective altruism’s early days, although he now denies any link.
The effective altruism movement, which has close ties to the AI community and the companies leading the artificial intelligence boom, has drawn mainstream attention and accusations of cultlike behavior and alarmism.
The hard-to-define movement is still growing and wants to better explain its values amid bitter criticism from the Trump administration and some powerful voices in Silicon Valley.
Its founding principle is to give money or time to major causes as effectively as possible, an intentionally dispassionate approach that has at times been called out of touch.
The New York Post called it a "wacky cult," the conservative Daily Caller dubbed it "The AI Doomsday Cartel," and a White House memo accused it of preferring the saving of "shrimp over families."
Once little known outside the tech world and some academic and political circles, effective altruism (EA) has been in the spotlight in recent weeks after a series of warnings about AI risks.
Those warnings were linked to EA. David Sacks, a venture capitalist and adviser to President Donald Trump, argued that organizations tied to EA are part of a "Doomer Industrial Complex" pushing for tougher AI regulation.
EA is deeply rooted in Silicon Valley and counts controlling AI's dangers among its priorities.
Anthropic chief executive Dario Amodei is considered a key figure in EA's early days, although he now distances himself from the movement.
Anthropic President Daniela Amodei, Dario's sister, is married to Holden Karnofsky, an Anthropic employee and a leading EA proponent.
The movement has also influenced researchers and staff at other AI companies, including ChatGPT maker OpenAI, particularly those working on AI safety.
The movement, which took shape about 15 years ago, is used to criticism.
Wealthy EA donors have often been accused of self-importance and of believing they alone know how best to give.
"Our ideas are just strange enough that people genuinely misinterpret them sometimes, and we can do a better job explaining how effective altruism approaches hard questions and tradeoffs," said Zachary Robinson, head of the Centre for Effective Altruism.
Robinson, whose organization supports the movement without directing it, sees the scrutiny since the summer as an opportunity to open up rather than retreat, because "people are curious to learn about us now."
After growing steadily until 2022, EA was badly damaged by the collapse of cryptocurrency platform FTX and its founder Sam Bankman-Fried, once the face of EA and later convicted of fraud.
After several difficult years, "We're on an up right now," Robinson said, pointing to attendance at the EA Global conference in New York in mid-October.
Like many at EA Global, Shanil Wijesinghe, who works at a Canadian nonprofit, rejected the image of EA as monolithic. "It is a values-based movement and not an identity-based movement," he said.
"We're all trying to do the most good, with the resources we have," he said. Those values "can be interpreted differently, and I think we have to embrace those differences."
EA has no leader or spokesperson. Sjir Hoeijmakers, head of the charity platform Giving What We Can, said that is a good thing, even if it means "sometimes the story doesn't get told."
Still, "effective altruism is now a movement large enough that it's actually really influencing the world, and that's getting noticed," he said.
"I think the work that they're doing has been quite valuable," said Nadav Brandes, a genetics researcher also at EA Global, referring to AI safety.
"Without those pioneers ... nobody would still today take this issue very seriously," he added.
Brandes said he was initially skeptical when AI became a major EA cause, joining climate change and animal welfare.
"It was even a little bit off-putting to me," he recalled. "I was totally wrong about it."
Robinson stressed, however, that EA is about more than AI.
"The cause that gets the most emphasis right now is AI safety, but I think it would be false to say EA is AI safety," he said.
"If you look at the money side of things, actually, it's been the case for many years that global health and development gets much more money than AI," he said.
Who's behind this story?
Master's in physics with research experience. Long-time science news enthusiast. Plays key role in Science X's editorial success. Full profile →
Citation: Under fire over AI, effective altruism wants to tell its own story (2026, November 9) retrieved 9 November 2026 from https://techxplore.com/news/2026-11-ai-effective-altruism-story.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.
Get Instant Summarized Text (Gist)
Effective altruism promotes allocating money and time to maximize benefits across causes, including global health, animal welfare and AI safety. Its AI ties have drawn criticism and scrutiny, prompting efforts to clarify its values. Global health and development receive more funding than AI safety within the movement.
This summary was automatically generated using LLM. Full disclaimer
This site uses cookies to assist with navigation, analyse your use of our services, collect data for ads personalisation and provide content from third parties. By using our site, you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
原文为英文,正文由自动抓取并保留原文。
原文发布于 TechXplore(Under fire over AI, effective altruism wants to tell its own story),标题、摘要与正文由机器翻译,术语按行业惯例统一,未经人工逐句校订。
