11-19 更新 实时
首页/ 科技公司/ 正文

Google 的 AI 优先搜索给学校和企业带来挑战

科技公司 来源:AI Business 2026-11-06 22:55 0 阅读 机器翻译
Google 的 AI 优先搜索给学校和企业带来挑战

Kinza Yasar,新闻撰稿人

igoriss via Getty Images

Google 对 Search 的最新改动正迫使学校管理者做出一个艰难抉择:要么允许学生使用内置 AI 功能的搜索引擎,要么彻底放弃 Google Search。

在 11 月 3 日发布于官方博客的一篇文章中,该公司表示,自 2027 年初起,将默认对学校管理的 K-12 账户禁用 Search、Gemini、Gemini Notebook 和 Gemini in Classroom。学校管理者可以单独启用或禁用这四项服务。不过,启用 Google Search 也意味着启用其集成的 AI 功能,包括 AI Overviews 和 AI Mode。

Google 还将把 Guided Learning 引入 Search。这一由 AI 驱动的功能帮助学生一步步解决问题,而不是直接给出答案。公司将于本月晚些时候在部分美国学校率先测试这一新功能,之后再推广至其他学区。

这一决定推翻了 8 月出台的一项默认启用 Gemini in Classroom 的政策,此前教育工作者提出反对,美国参议员 Richard Blumenthal(康涅狄格州民主党)和 Josh Hawley(密苏里州共和党)也对此进行了审视。Google 教育业务负责人 Chris Phillips 对 Chalkbeat 表示,想要禁止 AI 的学校将不得不放弃 Search,公司称其已将 AI 与 Search 深度整合。

但对这家科技巨头的母公司 Alphabet 而言,这一决定折射出一个更大的问题:Google 正让 AI 与 Search 变得越来越不可分割,同时又面临外界质疑——它能否将 AI 驱动的活动转化为可持续的收入。这一转变也影响到依赖 Google 触达客户、投放广告和获取网站流量的企业。

在该公司最近召开的第三季度财报电话会议上,Google 高级副总裁兼首席商务官 Philipp Schindler 承认,AI Mode 查询的变现能力下降拖累了搜索业务的收入增长。受此影响,Alphabet 股价上周遭遇史上最大跌幅,暴跌 13%。本周该股小幅反弹,随后又被卷入周四由中期选举引发的科技与 AI 相关股票大规模抛售之中。

尽管存在广告风险,Google 仍坚持 AI 优先

传统网页搜索向用户呈现链接,供其自行评估和比较。AI 搜索则将这一过程压缩为生成的摘要和多轮对话。

对学校而言,这意味着它们无法再只提供常规搜索结果,而不让学生接触到 AI 生成的答案。对广告主和出版商而言,AI 答案可能改变用户发现信息、接触广告以及与商业内容互动的方式。

Yoast 的首席 SEO、SEO 与 AI 咨询公司 CSHEL Search Strategies 创始人 Carolyn Shelby 表示,Google 之所以仍继续推进,是因为不这么做可能后果更糟。

Shelby 说:“Google 实际上是被迫在别人蚕食自己之前,先蚕食自己的业务。”传统搜索让 Google 在用户从最初调研到比较、再到购买的整个旅程中拥有多次变现机会。她说,AI 生成的答案可能将这些互动压缩进一次对话,从而减少展示广告的机会。

竞争是 Google 推进 AI 搜索的另一个原因。Shelby 说:“OpenAI 等竞争对手正在扩展其搜索能力,Google 面临留住用户的压力,即便这样做会颠覆其传统广告模式。”

这一转变也反映出,随着 AI 改变在线搜索行为,企业普遍需要重新思考如何吸引和留住客户。

Google「AI 优先」搜索战略的财务风险

Google 决定让 AI 与搜索密不可分——即便对希望限制学生访问的学校也是如此——这体现了其更广泛的「AI 优先」战略。但目前尚不清楚,该公司能否像通过传统搜索那样,有效地从 AI 驱动的交互中实现变现。

在 AI 可见性与分析平台 Searchable 追踪的美国和英国 AI 聊天机器人用户中,如今 14% 的与购物相关的 Google 搜索发生在 AI Mode 中,一年前这一比例约为 2%。Searchable 的 AEO(答案引擎优化)与 SEO 负责人 JP Garbaccio 表示,这些查询中包含「best」「cheapest」「price」等词。

Garbaccio 表示:「AI 搜索正在蚕食 Google 的传统业务,而其中很大一部分是 Google 在蚕食自己。」「用户仍留在 Google,这比被 ChatGPT 抢走要有利得多,但变现的打法必须改变。」

Google 的搜索收入增长也在放缓。2026 年第三季度,搜索及其他业务收入达到 633.5 亿美元,但同比增速从第一季度的 19% 降至第二季度的 17%,再到第三季度的 12%。Google 正试图通过在 AI Overviews 中扩大广告投放、并在 AI Mode 中测试对话式广告来弥合这一差距。但广告主仍需判断,用户在 AI 对话过程中的哪个时点最容易接受广告。

Garbaccio 表示:「AI Mode 的对话平均包含近三个问题,这使得判断广告或产品推荐在哪个节点最相关变得更加困难。」

问题不止于决定在哪里投放广告。Google还必须考虑生成AI回答的成本,尤其是当这些对话取代了原本会展示广告的传统搜索时。

“如果一段AI对话取代了若干可盈利的传统搜索,Google就必须在回收那部分收入的同时,还要为生成答案付费,”Golden Bear Capital的独立股票研究员Jacopo Viganò表示。

Viganò表示,这种担忧部分取决于AI Mode是取代了现有搜索,还是带来了更多搜索活动——而Google主张是后者。

Schindler在Google财报电话会议上表示,大多数AI Mode查询属于增量,产生了原本可能不会发生的搜索活动。这些互动可能创造更多广告机会,但Google仍需证明由此产生的收入足以覆盖生成AI回答的成本。

Google以AI为先的搜索可能侵蚀它所依赖的内容

Google的AI搜索战略还威胁到让搜索变得有用的内容生态。出版商和零售商长期以来投入原创内容,以通过搜索推荐吸引访客。AI概览可能降低用户点击跳转的需求,从而可能削弱原创出版的一处资金来源。

研究表明,这种转变已经在影响用户行为。一项2026年涉及1100名Google用户的实地实验发现,AI驱动的搜索减少了跳转至外部网站的点击,而移除Google的AI功能则提高了出版商的点击率。

对于依赖自然搜索来获客的企业而言,推荐流量减少会让内容投入更难被证明合理,即便这些内容对 Google 的 AI 生成答案依然重要。这让 Google 陷入不得不推翻自己推广了数十年之说的境地。

"Google 基本上花了 25 年教企业为点击付费——而现在它却要教用户不要点击,"Shelby 说。

Google 决定让学校管理的账户自行选择是否启用 AI 功能,这体现出它在更广范围内推动将 AI 整合进搜索,即便一些机构更偏好传统的搜索体验。这一推动的影响并不限于学校,还波及那些提供内容、让搜索变得有用的企业和出版商。

更长远的问题是,Google 能否让企业和出版商持续创作其搜索与 AI 产品所依赖的原创内容。

"如果这些企业无法再从创作这些信息中获得回报,五年后 Google 答案的质量和时效性会变成什么样?"Shelby 说。

Kinza Yasar 为 TechTarget 报道 AI 与新兴技术,重点关注伦理、企业采用、治理与商业战略。在转入新闻行业之前,她从事 IT 与网络支持工作,这让她能从系统层面审视企业技术如何构建、部署和管理。

想在 Google 搜索结果中看到更多 AI Business 报道吗?

译文由英文原文机器翻译,术语按行业惯例统一,可在文末展开原文核对。

查看英文原文(Google's AI-first Search creates challenges for schools and businesses)

Picture of Kinza Yasar

Kinza Yasar,News Writer

igoriss via Getty Images

Google's latest changes to Search are forcing school administrators to make a hard choice: allow students to use a search engine with built-in AI features or give up Google Search altogether.

In a November 3 post on its official blog, the company said it would disable Search, Gemini, Gemini Notebook and Gemini in Classroom by default for school-managed K-12 accounts starting in early 2027. School administrators can independently enable or disable each of the four services. However, enabling Google Search also means enabling its integrated AI features, including AI Overviews and AI Mode.

Google is also bringing Guided Learning, an AI-powered feature that helps students work through problems step by step rather than simply providing answers, into Search. It will initially test the new feature in select U.S. schools later this month before expanding it to other school districts.

The decision reverses an August policy that enabled Gemini in Classroom by default, following pushback from educators and scrutiny from U.S. Senators Richard Blumenthal, D-Conn and Josh Hawley, R-Mo. Google education chief Chris Phillips told Chalkbeat that schools wanting to prohibit AI will have to give up Search, which the company said it has deeply integrated with AI.

But the decision reflects a larger problem for Alphabet, the tech giant’s parent company: Google is making AI increasingly inseparable from Search, while facing questions about whether it can turn AI-driven activity into sustainable revenue. The shift also affects businesses that depend on Google for customer reach, advertising and website traffic.

On the vendor’s recent Q3 earnings call, Google's senior vice president and chief business officer Philipp Schindler acknowledged that reduced monetization of AI Mode queries hurt Search revenue growth. As a result, Alphabet shares suffered their biggest drop ever last week, plummeting 13%. The stock rebounded modestly this week before getting caught up in Thursday’s massive mid-term election, tech and AI-related stocks selloff.

Google going AI-first despite the ad risk

Traditional web search presents users with links to evaluate and compare. AI search condenses that into generated summaries and multiturn conversations.

For schools, this means they can no longer offer conventional search results without also exposing students to AI-generated answers. For advertisers and publishers, AI answers could change how users discover information, encounter ads and interact with commercial content.

Google is pressing ahead anyway because the alternative could be worse, said Carolyn Shelby, a principal SEO at Yoast and founder of CSHEL Search Strategies, an SEO and AI advisory firm.

"Google is essentially being forced to cannibalize its own business before somebody else does," Shelby said. Traditional Search gives Google multiple opportunities to monetize a user's journey, from initial research through comparison and purchase. AI-generated answers can compress those interactions into a single conversation, reducing opportunities to display ads, she said.

Competition is another reason Google is pushing ahead with AI-powered Search. "Competitors such as OpenAI are expanding their search capabilities, and Google faces pressure to retain users, even if doing so disrupts its traditional advertising model," Shelby said.

This shift also reflects a broader need for businesses to rethink how they attract and retain customers as AI changes online search behavior.

The financial risks of Google's AI-first Search strategy

Google's decision to make AI inseparable from Search, even for schools seeking to restrict students' access, reflects its broader AI-first strategy. But it’s unclear whether the company can monetize AI-driven interactions as effectively as it can with traditional search.

Among U.S. and U.K. AI chatbot users tracked by AI visibility and analytics platform Searchable, 14% of shopping-related Google searches now take place in AI Mode, up from roughly 2% a year ago. These include queries containing terms such as "best," "cheapest" and "price," said JP Garbaccio, head of AEO (answer engine optimization) and SEO at Searchable.

"AI search is eating into Google's traditional business, and plenty of that is Google eating into itself," Garbaccio said. "Users are staying with Google, which is a far stronger position than losing them to ChatGPT, but the monetization playbook has to change."

Google's Search revenue growth is also slowing. Search and other revenue reached $63.35 billion in the third quarter of 2026, but year-over-year growth fell from 19% in the first quarter to 17% in the second and 12% in the third. Google is trying to close that gap by expanding ad placements in AI Overviews and testing conversational ads in AI Mode. But advertisers still need to identify when users are most receptive to ads during an AI conversation.

"AI Mode conversations average nearly three questions, making it harder to identify the point at which an ad or product recommendation is most relevant," Garbaccio said.

The problem goes beyond deciding where to place ads. Google must also account for the cost of generating AI responses, especially when those conversations replace traditional searches that would have displayed ads.

"If an AI conversation replaces several profitable conventional searches, Google has to recover that revenue while also paying to generate the answers," said Jacopo Viganò, an independent equity researcher at Golden Bear Capital.

Viganò's said that concern partly depends on whether AI Mode replaces existing searches or generates more activity. which Google argues is happening.

Schindler said during the Google earnings call that most AI Mode queries are incremental, generating search activity that might not otherwise have occurred. Those interactions could create more advertising opportunities, but Google still needs to demonstrate that the resulting revenue covers the cost of generating AI responses.

Google’s AI-first Search could erode the content it depends on

Google's AI search strategy also threatens the content ecosystem that makes Search useful. Publishers and retailers have long invested in original content to attract visitors through search referrals. AI Overviews can reduce the need for users to click through, potentially weakening a source of funding for original publishing.

Research suggests this shift is already affecting user behavior. A 2026 field experiment involving 1,100 Google users found that AI-powered search reduced clicks to external websites, while removing Google's AI features increased publisher click-through rates.

For businesses that rely on organic search to attract customers, reduced referral traffic could make content investments harder to justify, even as that content remains important to Google's AI-generated answers. That puts Google in the position of reversing a message it has promoted for decades.

"Google has basically spent 25 years teaching businesses to pay for clicks - and now it has to teach users not to click," Shelby said.

Google's decision to make AI features optional for school-managed accounts illustrates its broader push to integrate AI into Search, even when some institutions prefer a traditional search experience. That same push has implications beyond schools, including for the businesses and publishers whose content helps make Search useful.

The longer-term question is whether Google can keep businesses and publishers creating the original content that its Search and AI products rely on.

"If those businesses stop getting a return on creating that information, what happens to the quality and freshness of Google's answers five years from now?" Shelby said.

Kinza Yasar covers AI and emerging technology for TechTarget, with a focus on ethics, enterprise adoption, governance and business strategy. Before moving into journalism, she worked in IT and network support roles, giving her a systems-level perspective on how enterprise technologies are built, deployed and managed.

Want more AI Business stories in your Google search results?

原文为英文,正文由自动抓取并保留原文。

本文由采集器自动同步

原文发布于 AI Business(Google's AI-first Search creates challenges for schools and businesses),标题、摘要与正文由机器翻译,术语按行业惯例统一,未经人工逐句校订。

阅读原文 ↗