11-19 更新 实时
首页/ 科技公司/ 正文

谷歌 AI 搜索失误令学校陷入困境

科技公司 来源:9to5Google 2026-11-05 20:00 0 阅读 机器翻译
谷歌 AI 搜索失误令学校陷入困境

Daniel Bader | 2026年11月5日 - 太平洋时间凌晨4:00

早上好,祝所有庆祝 Ocarina of Time 日的人节日快乐。哦,说到庆祝:恭喜中期选举的真正赢家——YouTube 和 Twitch 主播们。

Inbox 由 Daniel Bader 撰写。往期内容可在此阅读,之后还可以看看 Ben Schoon 每周日发布的精彩专栏 Weekender。

美国各学区对 Google 的依赖程度之高,怎么形容都不为过。全国几乎每个学区教育委员会都会为学生购买 Chromebook,许多学生还能把它们带回家,当作个人笔记本电脑使用。IT 和采购经理喜欢这类设备,因为它们相对便宜,并支持零接触注册,从而降低了前期和后续的维护成本。教师也喜欢它们,因为 Google Classroom 相对直观,而 ChromeOS 针对大多数其他基于网页的教育平台都做了优化。

本周早些时候,事情发展到紧要关头:《纽约时报》报道称,学校里 Google 搜索体验的调整将要求学生选择启用 Gemini、Gemini Notebook、Gemini in Classroom,以及或许最重要的 AI Overviews。此举实际上是在 Google 受到压力、被要求让学生对 AI 的使用改为选择性加入之后推出的。Google 的理由是:搜索和 AI 如今在技术栈中已“深度整合”,因此禁用其中一个就意味着禁用另一个。

Google 针对 AI Overviews 给出的替代方案是一项名为 Guided Learning 的新功能,它用一个帮助学生理解问题的分步指南,取代了搜索的核心功能——解决问题。

前FTC主席Lina Khan在X上发文抨击这一举措:“Google正在利用其搜索垄断地位,胁迫学校采用AI,”她说。“这凸显出允许一家不受监管的垄断者掌控一项基本服务的危险。多家法院已认定Google违反反垄断法,而这一最新举动表明它依然毫无收敛。随着公众对学校使用AI的反对声日益高涨,Google正在明确表示,它会惩罚那些不服从的人。”

我感觉Google会以某种形式收回这一决定。正如9to5的Ben Schoon所指出的,在当前版本的Google搜索中,禁用AI Overviews简单得近乎滑稽,而且似乎并未对后续搜索结果造成不利影响。但Google很可能担心,如果被迫为特定用户群体单独划分出不同版本的搜索体验,其蓬勃发展的AI Overviews广告业务收入可能会受到影响。

即便Google坚持己见,此举也暴露出公众——尤其是家长——与那些向用户强推AI的科技巨头之间的裂痕。此外,AI热潮还直接影响了教育工作者购买新硬件、升级老旧Chromebook设备的能力,因为过去一年零部件价格上涨了多达5倍。一些低收入学区甚至从学生手中收回Chromebook,重新回到共享笔记本电脑池的模式以节省开支。

Redmagic 12 Pro评测:你从未在这样的手机上玩过游戏。我们本周在The Sideload中谈到了这款手机:随着Android在游戏方面越做越好,我认为游戏手机对Android而言将越来越重要。

在 iPhone Duo 发布和“裂屏门”风波中,Galaxy Z Fold 8 销量激增。iPhone Duo 的屏幕问题或许还称不上丑闻,但三星在这一品类的领先地位从未显得如此稳固。

Android Auto 18.1 更新正在推送,为浅色模式和重新设计做了更多准备。又一次小幅改版即将到来,而它可以说是目前最好的 Android 版本。

OpenAI 称,ChatGPT 的体量已达到 Google 搜索量的约 20%。这个数字仅用四年就实现,令人震惊。难怪 Google 会慌。

Peak Design 的新款无线充电支架名副其实地一物两用。早在今年 1 月的 CES 上我就见过这些原型机,最终版本看起来精致得多。期待上手试用。

Google Photos 现在允许你关闭“回忆”功能中的背景音乐。谢天谢地。我真的讨厌这个功能。

微软表示,现在使用配备 8GB 内存的 Windows PC 体验没那么糟了。看来在效率上下功夫的不只是 Google 一家。

上市三个月后,Galaxy Z Fold 8 的摄像头仍不够用,而 Fold 9 可能也解决不了这个问题。Ben 说得完全对:我很喜欢我的 Fold 8,但它的摄像头简直糟糕透顶。

Nothing 预告下月发布无屏产品,“不可能只是一个应用”。这听起来确实像是某种能记录你每一次互动的设备。总不能是 Bee 吧?

「Enough Phone」是一款 Android 手机,尺寸大致与 iPhone 13 Mini 相当,将于 2027 年推出。我必须敬佩这种胆量——推出一款几乎注定只会是一代产品的手机,但这真的是人们在 2027 年想要的吗?

如果你想与 Google Search 建立一种远没那么复杂的关系,不妨试试它的《时之笛》彩蛋。搜索「Zelda」或「Ocarina of Time」,然后点击大师之剑,就能回到 1998 年风格的搜索结果页面,还配有 Link 的音效。这是一趟回忆之旅,回到那个——连 Google 自己也承认——一切都简单得多的时代。

AI 出现在选票上了吗?据 Stratechery 的 Ben Thompson 说,它占了很大的分量。民主党和共和党都否决了数据中心,但民主党希望真正通过一些监管,来约束超大规模厂商和前沿实验室的野心。

起初我们缺算力,但算力很快扩产了;现在我们缺内存,但这也会扩产;我们曾接近缺电力的边缘,但这也会得到解决。最终的制约是政治,而这也许是所有制约中最难逾越的。它不仅更难解决,而且实际上会干扰其他制约的解决。许多关于 AI 的理论都假设它会变成一种大宗商品;我认为同样可能的是,我们面对稀缺的时间会远超预期,而这将对一切产生连锁反应。

有没有可能通过广泛的 AI 监管,去放慢一个自 2024 年特朗普再次当选以来一直被放任不管的行业?而且,即便这意味着在两大 AI 实验室 Anthropic 和 OpenAI 即将 IPO 之际遭遇短期放缓,支持这样的监管是否符合这些公司自身的最佳利益?

63亿美元的 Binance 黑客事件出现了一些引人关注的进展:原来这又是一起社会工程案例。一名 Binance 工程师被诱骗参加一场虚假的求职面试,而在面试前他下载了恶意软件,让黑客得以入侵他的电脑,并最终侵入网络上的其他设备。

上周我和 Will 讨论完“浏览器的消亡”之后,得知 Brave 被《纽约时报》以侵犯版权为由起诉,我并不感到意外。Brave 被指控从 nytimes.com 等网站抓取付费墙后的内容,并通过搜索 API 将其访问权出售给 AI 公司,供其用作训练数据。没错,作为浏览器厂商赚钱确实很难(Arc 是另一个很有说服力的例子),但即便对一家熟悉灰色商业操作的公司来说,这种做法也尤为恶劣。

喜欢刚刚读到的内容?今天就订阅 Inbox,每周二和周四早上即可在邮箱中收到。

你也可以通过成为 9to5Google Pro 会员来支持我们,每月仅需 5 美元起。你将获得播客加更节目、访问会员专属 Discord 服务器的权限,以及更多内容。

感谢阅读,祝你今天愉快。我们周二再聊。

Daniel 是一名撰稿人、编辑、播客主播和分析师,报道科技界重大时刻背后的重大新闻、小型里程碑以及了不起的人物。他曾任 MobileSyrup、Android Central 和 Android Police 的主编,自 2010 年以来一直担任科技出版物的内容总监。

译文由英文原文机器翻译,术语按行业惯例统一,可在文末展开原文核对。

查看英文原文(Google’s AI search fumbles leave schools in the lurch)

Google's AI search fumbles leave schools in the lurch

Google’s AI search fumbles leave schools in the lurch

Avatar for Daniel BaderDaniel Bader | Nov 5 2026 - 4:00 am PT

Good morning, and happy Ocarina of Time day to all who celebrate. Oh, and speaking of celebrating: congratulations to the real winners of the midterms, YouTube and Twitch streamers.

Inbox is the tech newsletter that goes beyond the news cycle. We cover the most important 9to5Google stories from the last couple of days along with a few highlights from around the web. We publish every Tuesday and Thursday, and if you like what you read, please subscribe.

Inbox is written by Daniel Bader. Read previous issues here, and then catch up with Ben Schoon’s excellent Weekender column published every Sunday.

It’s hard to overstate how reliant US school districts are on Google. Almost every school board in the country purchases Chromebooks for their students, many of whom are able to take them home and treat them as personal laptops. IT and procurement managers like them because they’re relatively cheap and offer zero-touch enrollment, which lowers upfront and ongoing maintenance costs. Teachers also like them because Google Classroom is relatively intuitive and ChromeOS is optimized for most other web-based education platforms.

Advertisement - scroll for more content

But this reliance on Google’s tech stack comes at a cost: school boards are forced to comply with the company’s capricious terms of service, in particular when it comes to the creeping proliferation of AI across its products.

Things came to a head earlier this week when the New York Times reported that changes to the Google Search experience in schools will require opting into Gemini, Gemini Notebook, Gemini in Classroom, and, perhaps most importantly, AI Overviews. The move actually comes after Google was pressured to make student AI usage opt-in. Google’s justification: search and AI are now “deeply integrated” in the tech stack, so disabling one means disabling the other.

Google’s alternative to AI Overviews is a new Guided Learning feature, which replaces search’s primary function — solving a problem — with a step-by-step guide that helps a student understand said problem.

Former FTC Chair Lina Khan took to X to decry the move: “Google is using its search monopoly to coerce schools into adopting AI,” she said. “This highlights the danger of allowing an unregulated monopolist to control an essential service. Multiple courts have found Google liable for violating antitrust laws, and this latest move shows it remains unchastened. As the public increasingly pushes back against the use of AI in schools, Google is making clear it will punish those who don’t fall in line.”

I have a feeling Google will need to walk back this decision in some form. As 9to5’s Ben Schoon points out, it’s comically easy to disable AI Overviews in the current version of Google Search, and it doesn’t seem to have a detrimental impact on the subsequent results. But Google is likely worried that if it is forced to carve out versions of the search experience for specific user bases, revenue from its burgeoning AI Overviews ad business may be impacted.

Even if Google sticks to its proverbial guns, the move exposes a rift between the public, particularly parents, and the tech giants pushing AI on their users. Furthermore, the AI boom has had a direct impact on educators’ ability to purchase new hardware and upgrade old Chromebook fleets, since component prices have increased by as much as 5x over the past year. Some lower-income districts are even recalling Chromebooks from students, reverting to a shared laptop pool to save money.

Redmagic 12 Pro review: You’ve never gamed on a phone like this before. We talked about this phone on The Sideload this week: as Android gets better for games, I think gaming phones will be increasingly important for Android.

Galaxy Z Fold 8 sales spike amid iPhone Duo release and ‘crackgate’ debacle. The iPhone Duo’s display issues may not yet constitute a scandal, but Samsung’s category lead has never seemed so assured.

Android Auto 18.1 update rolling out with additional prep for light mode and redesign. Another minor redesign is coming to what is arguably the best version of Android out there.

ChatGPT has hit roughly 20% of Google Search volume, OpenAI says. This is a staggering number achieved in only four years. It’s no wonder Google is freaking out.

Peak Design’s new wireless charging stand pulls double duty, literally. I saw prototypes for these way back at CES in January, and the final versions look way more polished. Looking forward to trying them.

Google Photos now lets you turn off background music in Memories. Thank goodness. I genuinely hate this feature.

Microsoft says it now sucks less to use a Windows PC with 8GB of RAM. Seems like Google isn’t the only company doubling down on efficiency.

Three months in, Galaxy Z Fold 8’s cameras aren’t enough, and Fold 9 might not fix it. Ben’s absolutely right about this: I love my Fold 8, but its cameras are straight-up terrible.

Nothing teases screen-less product launching next month, ‘couldn’t have been an app’. This certainly sounds like something that records your every interaction. Couldn’t Bee, right?

‘Enough Phone’ is an Android phone roughly the size of iPhone 13 Mini, launching in 2027. I have to respect the gumption of releasing a phone that will almost certainly be a one-off, but is this what people are really after in 2027?

For a much less complicated relationship with Google Search, try its Ocarina of Time Easter egg. Search for “Zelda” or “Ocarina of Time,” then tap the Master Sword to travel back to a 1998-style results page, complete with Link’s sound effects. It’s a trip down memory lane to a time when, as even Google acknowledges, things were a whole lot simpler.

Was AI on the ballot? According to Ben Thompson at Stratechery, it was in a big way. Democrats and Republicans both rejected data centers, but Democrats want to actually pass some regulation reining in the hyperscalers’ and frontier labs’ ambitions.

First we were short on compute, but that ramped; now we are short on memory, but that will ramp; we were coming close to being short on power, but that will be rectified. The final constraint is political, and that may be the most imposing constraint of all. Not only is it harder to solve, but it actually interferes with solving the other constraints. Many of the theories about AI assume that it becomes a commodity; I think it’s just as likely we are looking at scarcity for much longer than we expected, which will have ripple effects on everything.

Is it possible to pass broad AI regulation that will slow down an industry that has been allowed to run unchecked since Trump’s reelection in 2024? And is it in the best interest of these companies to support it, even if it means a short-term slowdown at a time when the two biggest AI labs, Anthropic and OpenAI, are about to IPO?

Some fascinating developments in the $6.3 billion Binance hack: turns out it was yet another case of social engineering. A Binance engineer was lured into a fake job interview, before which he downloaded malware that let hackers breach his computer and, eventually, others on the network.

After my discussion with Will last week about the death of browsers, it came as no surprise to learn that Brave is being sued by the New York Times for copyright infringement. Brave is accused of scraping paywalled material from sites like nytimes.com and selling access to it through a search API to AI companies, which use it as training data. Yes, it’s difficult to earn money as a browser maker (see Arc for another compelling example), but this is particularly egregious, even for a company familiar with shady business practices.

Like what you just read? Subscribe to Inbox today and get it in your email every Tuesday and Thursday morning. Got feedback? Send us an email.

You can also support us by becoming a 9to5Google Pro member, starting at just $5/month. You get bonus podcast episodes, access to our members-only Discord server, and lots more.

Thanks for reading, and have a great day. I’ll talk to you on Tuesday.

Daniel is a writer, editor, podcaster and analyst covering the big stories, small milestones, and amazing people behind tech’s biggest moments. He was previously editor-in-chief of MobileSyrup, Android Central, and Android Police, and has been a content director of tech publications since 2010.

原文为英文,正文由自动抓取并保留原文。

本文由采集器自动同步

原文发布于 9to5Google(Google’s AI search fumbles leave schools in the lurch),标题、摘要与正文由机器翻译,术语按行业惯例统一,未经人工逐句校订。

阅读原文 ↗