11-19 更新 实时
首页/ 科技公司/ 正文

Google 强推 AI Overviews,学校寻求退路

科技公司 来源:Wired 2026-11-05 04:06 0 阅读 机器翻译
Google 强推 AI Overviews,学校寻求退路

“这似乎与我们试图教给学生的东西背道而驰,”这位管理人员写道。“学生需要有机会去浏览搜索结果、审视信息来源、并得出自己的结论,而不是还没开始就被塞给一份 AI 生成的综合答案。”

Google 方面没有人回应这一担忧,而这一担忧已经发酵多年。但来自另外三个学区的同行也表达了类似的沮丧,并指出了他们正在采用或考虑采用的一些变通办法,用以在缺乏官方“关闭”开关的情况下屏蔽 AI Overviews。他们的专长即将变得抢手。

Google 周二宣布,拒绝为学校提供禁用 AI Overviews 的选项。相反,从明年开始,学校若想摆脱这一功能,就必须彻底屏蔽对搜索的访问。这一决定令全美教育工作者、家长和技术研究人员感到震惊。

“我们完全惊呆了,”俄勒冈州一个名为 Lake Oswego Parents for Responsible Technology 的社区组织的成员 Dominique Johnson 说。“这一举措让那些已认定 AI 有害于基础学习的学区处境更加艰难。”

Google 未回应置评请求。但在 X 上就这一争议作出的公开回应中,该公司辩称,学校如今将拥有“更多而非更少的选择”,因为从明年起,搜索、其 Gemini 聊天机器人以及 Gemini Notebook 工具都将默认关闭。管理人员可以启用其中一项、两项或全部三项服务。

然而,对学校和家长而言,问题在于 Google 认为 AI Overviews 与一项名为 AI Mode 的配套功能与传统搜索体验不可分割。这两项功能分别于 2023 年和 2025 年推出,将 Gemini、ChatGPT 等 AI 聊天机器人的功能直接带入搜索结果之中。

“孩子们已经在利用这些搜索栏摘要来逃避真正的努力,直接获取即时的数学答案,还让 AI 替他们写作文,”Johnson 说。“更糟的是,这些 AI 快照经常出错、输出虚假事实,而年纪较小的学生却将其奉为绝对真理。”

这些 AI 生成的回答读起来很吸引人,而且往往足以让人信服,由此引发的麻烦远不止于课堂。随着人们依赖这些概览,Wikipedia、新闻网站和教育工具都流失了人类访客。Google 用同样的机器人抓取网络内容,用于其搜索和 AI 产品,这让出版商无法选择不让自己的内容被用于后者。

Google 力推让 AI Overviews 成为搜索的显著组成部分,这已经付出了代价。上周,其母公司 Alphabet 的股价遭遇了最惨烈的单日抛售,市值蒸发 5000 亿美元,此前该公司公布的搜索广告销售低于预期。一个重要原因?AI Overviews 和 AI Mode 的使用量增加,而这两者目前还没有塞满大量广告——尽管一些专家认为这种下滑只是暂时的。

对学校而言,关于搜索的两难困境可能才刚刚开始。WIRED 联系了多个学区,它们均未回应置评请求,而 Los Angeles Unified 表示仍在评估 Google 这一宣布可能带来的影响。一些教育科技专家认为,学校应当彻底弃用 Google 搜索,或者至少更着力地教导学生质疑 AI 答案的真实性。

“资源不足的学区会咬紧牙关说,‘我们没有能力坚持立场、不用Google,’”南加州大学(USC)生成式AI与社会中心联合主任Stephen Aguilar说。“许多学区很可能会加快他们已有的计划,向学生教授这种新的数字素养。”

家长倡导者也计划推动学区另寻他路。“这一举动只是延续了大型科技公司把产品推向课堂的一贯模式,”Karolle Rabarison说。她是一位政策与传播策略师,在华盛顿特区协助领导Schools Beyond Screens。“这种做法再也行不通了。”

科技行业资深人士对于Google要让学校在不影响Search其余功能的情况下禁用AI Overviews有多难,意见不一。“问题在于他们是否愿意长期维护两个版本的搜索,”Nicole Kerson说。她曾任Google Search高级产品经理,现经营AI战略公司Collected Company。“维护这样一个分叉的产品非常困难。”

微软提供了一个Google Chrome扩展程序,让用户可以在Bing搜索中关闭AI生成的摘要。Adeel Khan曾是一名教师和校长,现在经营MagicSchool,该公司为学生和教师提供AI聊天机器人。他说,Google没有做类似的事情“令人愤怒、侮辱且荒谬”。

由于没有官方途径禁用AI Overviews,学校转而采用技术变通方法,包括修改搜索URL和采用能改变Google搜索结果呈现方式的浏览器扩展。弗吉尼亚州费尔法克斯县公立学校(Fairfax County Public Schools)最近开发了自己的扩展程序。但如果Google改变搜索结果的呈现方式,这些漏洞可能就会失效。

规模较小的搜索引擎,例如主打隐私保护的 DuckDuckGo,看到了从对 Google 感到不满的学校手中赢得业务的机会。DuckDuckGo 发言人 Allison Goodman 表示:“我不指望短期内会出现 Google 风格的 DuckDuckGo Classroom,但理想情况下,我们会推出专门面向想要转换平台的教育工作者的资源。”

2024 年的一项联邦裁决认定 Google 非法维持其搜索垄断,此后该公司被要求与竞争对手共享某些搜索数据和服务,并放宽对其产品分发方式的限制。但由于持续的法律纠纷拖慢了负责监督这些补救措施的独立委员会的进度,相关工作已远远落后于计划。AI 概览(AI Overviews)问题可能引发新一轮审视,包括美国参议员 Bernie Sanders 在内的多位议员已批评 Google 对学校的立场。

斯坦福大学截至一年前对相关研究的综述显示,考察进入校园的新型 AI 工具影响的研究引发了担忧:这些工具是否正在侵蚀学生培养批判性思维等能力的机会。根据 Google 开展的一项调查,四分之三的青少年表示每周都会使用 AI,但只有约一半的人表示会核查其输出内容的准确性。与此同时,圣路易斯华盛顿大学最近的一项研究发现,只有约 42% 的 AI 概览能够通过其所附的引文得到完全核实。Google 表示,AI 概览经过严格测试,并在持续改进。

在回应近期围绕 AI Overviews 的风波时,Google 表示计划在未来几个月为学生推出一项名为 Guided Learning 的新功能。其理念是引导用户去寻找信息,而不是直接向他们提供答案。“我们认为,AI 产品应当支持‘productive struggle’(有成效的挣扎)——让学生受到积极挑战,又不至于不堪重负而放弃,”Google 教育副总裁 Chris Phillips 在周二的公司博客文章中写道。

一些研究人员已经在质疑 Guided Learning 会有多有效,认为它不会像与真人导师一起学习那样自然。Aguilar 将 Guided Learning 视为 Google 的又一次尝试,目的是维持其已经在美国课堂中占据的地位——在那里,由 Google 驱动的 Chromebook 笔记本电脑、Google Classroom 学习软件、Search 和 YouTube 司空见惯。

“我们必须要让学生为一个 AI 无处不在的世界做好准备,这种说法有几分道理,”Aguilar 说,“但这不应该通过一家公司发表非常自私自利的声明来实现,因为它在 AI 上投入巨大。”

他们兵棋推演了遮暗太阳——结果比你想象的更糟

实时追踪:Elon Musk 的 America PAC 正为中期选举大举支出

推出应用:更多充分利用 WIRED 的方式

Paresh Dave 是 WIRED 的高级撰稿人,报道大型科技公司的内部运作。他撰写应用和小工具如何被构建及其影响,同时为那些未受重视和处于弱势的人发声。他此前曾是 Reuters 和 Los Angeles Times 的记者,……阅读更多

译文由英文原文机器翻译,术语按行业惯例统一,可在文末展开原文核对。

查看英文原文(Google Is Forcing AI Overviews in Classrooms. Schools Are Searching for a Way Out)

“This seems counterproductive to what we're trying to teach,” the administrator wrote. “Students need opportunities to navigate search results, examine sources, and draw their own conclusions rather than being handed an AI-generated synthesis before they've even started.”

No one from Google responded to the concern, which has been bubbling up for years. But counterparts from three districts voiced similar frustration and pointed to work-arounds they were employing or considering to block AI Overviews in lieu of an official “off” switch. Their expertise is about to be in demand.

Google announced on Tuesday that it is declining to provide schools an option to disable AI Overviews. Instead, starting next year, schools will have to block access to search altogether to get rid of the feature. The decision has stunned educators, parents, and technology researchers across the US.

“We were flabbergasted,” says Dominique Johnson, part of an Oregon community group called Lake Oswego Parents for Responsible Technology. “This move makes things even more difficult for school districts that have determined AI is harmful to foundational learning.”

Google didn’t respond to a request for comment. But in a public response to the controversy shared on X, the company contended that schools will now have “more choice, not less” because search, its Gemini chatbot, and Gemini Notebook tool will be off by default starting next year. Administrators can enable one, two, or all three services.

The issue for schools and parents, though, is that Google considers AI Overviews and a companion feature called AI Mode inseparable from the traditional search experience. Respectively launched in 2023 and 2025, they bring the functionality of AI chatbots, such as Gemini or ChatGPT, directly into search results.

“Kids are already using these search-bar summaries to skip real effort, pulling instant math answers and letting AI write their essays,” Johnson says. “To make matters worse, these AI snapshots frequently make mistakes and output false facts, which younger students take as absolute truth.”

The AI-generated responses are tempting to read and are often good enough to trust, triggering headaches beyond classrooms. Wikipedia, news websites, and education tools have lost human visitors as people rely on overviews. Google uses the same bots to crawl the web for its search and AI products, making it impossible for publishers to opt out of their content being used for the latter.

Google’s push to make AI Overviews a prominent part of search has already come at a cost. Last week, shares of parent company Alphabet suffered their worst single-day selloff, erasing half a trillion dollars in market value after the company reported weaker-than-expected search ad sales. A big cause? Increased usage of AI Overviews and AI Mode, which aren’t packed with many ads yet—although some experts believe the slump will only be temporary.

For schools, the dilemma over search may be just beginning. While several districts WIRED contacted didn’t respond to requests for comment, Los Angeles Unified says it is still reviewing the potential implications of Google’s announcement. Some education technology experts argue that schools should abandon Google search altogether, or at least do a better job teaching students to question the validity of AI answers.

“Under-resourced districts will grit their teeth and say, ‘We don’t have the capacity to dig in our heels and not use Google,’” says Stephen Aguilar, who coleads the Center for Generative AI and Society at USC. “A lot are likely going to accelerate plans they already have to teach students about this new digital literacy.”

Parent advocates also plan to push districts to look elsewhere. “This move just continues a well-established pattern of big tech companies pushing products into classrooms,” says Karolle Rabarison, a policy and communications strategist who helps lead Schools Beyond Screens in Washington, DC. “It’s not going to work anymore.”

Tech industry veterans disagree about how difficult it would be for Google to let schools disable AI Overviews without affecting the rest of Search. “It’s a question of whether they’re committed to maintaining two versions of search in the long run,” says Nicole Kerson, a former senior Google Search product manager who runs the AI strategy firm Collected Company. “It's very hard to maintain a forked product like that.”

Microsoft offers a Google Chrome extension that lets users turn off AI-generated summaries in Bing search. Adeel Khan, a former teacher and principal who now runs MagicSchool, which provides AI chatbots for students and teachers, says it is “infuriating, insulting, and ludicrous” that Google isn’t doing something similar.

Without an official way to disable AI Overviews, schools have turned to technical work-arounds, including modifying search URLs and adopting browser extensions that change how Google results appear. Fairfax County Public Schools in Virginia recently developed its own extension. But these loopholes could stop functioning if Google changes how its search results are delivered.

Smaller search engines, such as the privacy-focused DuckDuckGo, see an opportunity to win business from schools frustrated with Google. “I wouldn't expect to see a Google-style DuckDuckGo Classroom anytime soon, but ideally, we'll have special resources just for educators looking to make a switch,” says spokesperson Allison Goodman.

Following a federal ruling in 2024 that Google illegally maintained its search monopoly, the company was ordered to share certain search data and services with rivals and loosen restrictions on how its products are distributed. But the effort is well behind schedule, thanks to ongoing legal disputes slowing the independent committee meant to oversee the remedies. The AI Overviews issue could prompt fresh scrutiny as several lawmakers, including US senator Bernie Sanders, criticized Google’s stance toward schools.

Studies examining the effects of the new AI tools entering schools have raised concerns about whether they are eroding opportunities for students to develop skills such as critical thinking, according to a Stanford review of the research as of a year ago. According to a survey conducted by Google, three in four teenagers report using AI weekly, but only about half say they check its outputs for accuracy. A recent study by Washington University in St. Louis, meanwhile, found that only about 42 percent of AI Overviews could be fully verified using the citations they contained. Google has said overviews undergo rigorous testing and are continually improving.

In its response to the recent furor over AI Overviews, Google said it plans to launch a new feature for students in the coming months called Guided Learning. The idea is to coach users to find information rather than provide them with an immediate answer. “We believe AI products should support ‘productive struggle’—enabling students to be actively challenged without getting so overwhelmed that they give up,” wrote Chris Phillips, Google’s vice president for education, in the company’s blog post on Tuesday.

Some researchers are already questioning how effective Guided Learning will be, arguing that it won’t be as natural as working with a human tutor. Aguilar views Guided Learning as another attempt by Google to maintain the position it already occupies in American classrooms, where Google-powered Chromebook laptops, Google Classroom learning software, Search, and YouTube are commonplace.

“There’s a kernel of truth in saying we have to prepare students for a world where AI is ubiquitous,” Aguilar says, “but it shouldn’t be through a company making a very self-serving pronouncement because it’s heavily invested in AI.”

They war-gamed dimming the sun—it went worse than you think

Live tracker: Elon Musk’s America PAC is spending big on the midterms

Introducing the app: More ways to make the most of WIRED

Paresh Dave is a senior writer for WIRED, covering the inner workings of Big Tech companies. He writes about how apps and gadgets are built and about their impacts while giving voice to the stories of the underappreciated and disadvantaged. He was previously a reporter for Reuters and the Los Angeles Times, ... Read More

原文为英文,正文由自动抓取并保留原文。

本文由采集器自动同步

原文发布于 Wired(Google Is Forcing AI Overviews in Classrooms. Schools Are Searching for a Way Out),标题、摘要与正文由机器翻译,术语按行业惯例统一,未经人工逐句校订。

阅读原文 ↗