11-19 更新 实时
首页/ 深度/ 正文

问答:AI 如何开始模拟“混乱”的人类心智

深度 来源:MIT News AI 2026-10-23 12:00 1 阅读 机器翻译
问答:AI 如何开始模拟“混乱”的人类心智

MIT 历史学系助理教授 Benjamin Lindquist 认为,生成式人工智能模型植根于20世纪中期工程师们的思想,他们相信,对于一台能像人一样思考的机器来说,一定程度的非理性是必不可少的。Lindquist 在 MIT Schwarzman 计算学院与电气工程与计算机科学系(EECS)设有联合聘任,同时也是信息与决策系统实验室的首席研究员。

Lindquist 在一篇发表于《Past and Present》期刊的新论文中写道,为了模仿创造性思维,这些 AI 先驱有意在原本用于确定性求解问题的算法中注入了随机性。在论文中,他将 AI 幻觉的起源追溯到这项早期研究,并提出,在试图构建模仿人类行为的机器时,创造力与可预测性之间必然存在权衡。MIT News 就这些观点采访了 Lindquist。

问:为什么早期的计算机工程师认为,需要向为逻辑和计算而设计的 AI 系统注入随机性和非理性?

答:在科学界和艺术界,长期以来有许多人物从理论上主张,偶然性在发现与创造力——在产生新想法的能力——中扮演着重要角色。他们把创造力等同于出人意料的逻辑跳跃,甚至等同于一种类似梦境的状态,让你能够从新的视角思考事物。

20 世纪 50 年代初,贝尔实验室(Bell Labs)的著名电气工程师 John Pierce 提出了一个颇为流行的观点:数学在艺术领域也很有价值。这一想法在早期计算领域的许多从业者中得到共鸣。当我们想到包含数学的艺术作品时,脑海中浮现的可能是某种极其有序而精确的东西,但 Pierce 得出的却是相反的结论。他认为,数学的用处恰恰在于它能把秩序从艺术中剔除出去。随后,数学可以以一种经过精密计算的方式,为艺术注入一抹出人意料的东西,以此摆脱陈词滥调,并加入一丝不规则性——而这恰恰可能带来洞见。

要想在本应可预测的计算机中加入不规则性,一种流行的做法是采用人工(或称随机)神经网络。许多早期神经网络都是由心理学家构建的,他们认为,人工神经网络让科学家得以搭建出大脑的模型,从而能够观察其内部正在发生什么,包括大脑如何犯下富有成效的错误。研究者并不把这些系统视为黑箱,而是相信它们能够打开心智这个黑箱,让科学家窥见内部,看到真正发生的一切混乱过程。

但在 AI 领域还存在另一个阵营,他们认为创造性思维不过是把“普通”思维做得更好而已。有意思的是,可以看看这两种理解智能与创造力的极为简化的启发式思路,以及它们如何契合、又如何不契合。当时的争论,正是要试图弄清人类创造力归根结底是什么,以及如何以机器的形式把人这种创造力重新构建出来。

问:这些早期的计算机工程师是如何看待 AI 的?这与我们今天对 AI 的理解有何不同?

A:当我们想到 AI 系统时,我们想到的是 ChatGPT 或 Claude。我们重视并使用这些系统,是因为它们给出的答案大多数时候是正确的。在这项研究中,最让我感兴趣的一点,是发现这些系统早期的许多倡导者重视它们的理由恰恰相反。他们想要的是一个偶尔会给出偏离其预期答案的系统。他们已经有能够给出合理、符合预期答案的系统。他们认为神经网络的价值在于,它们能给出出人意料的、甚至可能古怪离奇的答案。

我们今天之所以可能以不同的眼光看待这些系统,一个原因或许在于它们的运作方式。早期,这些系统只存在于实验室中,所以一个给出奇怪或错误输出的系统并不会真正带来现实世界中的后果。但如今,出于法律和金钱上的原因,OpenAI 或 Anthropic 都不希望自家的聊天机器人给出出人意料或有创造性的答案。这些系统中的“怪异”已被逐渐“打磨掉”。它们的核心可能仍然潜藏着那种特质,但如今这在很大程度上被压制了。

Q:那些引入随机性来模拟人类创造力的早期神经网络,是如何演变成 AI 领域的主流范式的?

A:在很长一段时间里,一种被称为“符号主义 AI”的特定 AI 是主流方法。本质上,符号主义 AI 认为世界建立在规则之上。AI 研究者的角色,就是尝试用事实和命题来重建关于世界的知识,并将其输入计算机。

神经网络借助随机性来解决问题,在 1950 年代开始受到关注,但很快就失宠了。Frank Rosenblatt 是一位心理学家,也是神经网络早期一位非常重要的人物,他英年早逝——1971 年,他在自己 43 岁生日当天意外去世。他个性极具魅力、作风强势,对基于神经网络的系统能做什么许下了许多宏大的承诺。到他去世时,向符号主义 AI 的转向已经在进行之中。倘若他当时还在世,事情或许会有所不同。

但神经网络从未消失。到 1980 年代,它们更多地转向了认知科学领域。要变得更强、更有用,神经网络需要大量数据和算力。直到互联网出现,这些才真正到位——海量数据变得可用,计算能力也开始提升。大约在 2012 年,神经网络开始超越并拉开与一种统计式机器学习的差距,此后便一路发展壮大。

问:通过研究 AI 的历史,我们能吸取哪些经验教训,为其发展提供参考?

A:我认为这里有一个警示性的教训。这些早期工程师的想法和经历告诉我们,我们可以努力消除幻觉——我们可以努力让 AI 以某种方式运作,从而不产生意外或不想要的答案——但这也会带来其他后果。这些历史人物确实触及了某些东西。AI 能给出的令人惊讶且富有创造性的结论,与错误或幻觉之间存在联系。当我们把系统构造成以某种方式表现时,就会有权衡取舍。也许不可能完全处在这个光谱的任一端,但当我们强力地追求某一件事时,往往会无意中牺牲其他东西。

译文由英文原文机器翻译,术语按行业惯例统一,可在文末展开原文核对。

查看英文原文(Q&A: How AI came to model the “messy” human mind)

Generative artificial intelligence models are rooted in ideas of mid-20th century engineers who thought some amount of irrationality was essential for a machine that could think like a human, contends Benjamin Lindquist, an assistant professor in the MIT History Section, who holds an MIT Schwarzman College of Computing shared position with the Department of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science (EECS) and is a principal investigator in the Laboratory for Information and Decision Systems. 

To mimic creative thinking, these AI pioneers intentionally injected randomness into algorithms designed to deterministically solve problems, Lindquist writes in a new paper that appears in the journal Past and Present. In the paper, he traces the origins of AI hallucinations back to this early research and suggests there will be inevitable tradeoffs between creativity and predictability when trying to build machines that mimic human behavior. MIT News spoke with Lindquist about these ideas.

Q: Why did early computer engineers believe they needed to inject randomness and irrationality into AI systems designed for logic and calculation? 

A: There is a long history of many figures in the world of science and art theorizing that chance plays an important part in discovery and creativity — in the ability to originate ideas. They equated creativity with unexpected leaps of logic, or even a dream-like state that allows you to think about things from a new perspective. 

In the early 1950s, one popular idea from John Pierce, who was a prominent electrical engineer at Bell Labs, was about math being valuable in the world of art. The idea was shared by a lot of people working in early computing. When we think of artwork that includes math, we may think of something very orderly and precise, but Pierce came to the opposite conclusion. He concluded that the utility of math is that it could remove order from art. Then in a very calculated way, math could add a burst of the unexpected as a means to deviate from clichés and add an element of irregularity which just might lead to insight. 

One popular way to add irregularity into otherwise predictable computers was through artificial (or random) neural networks. Many early neural networks were built by psychologists, who thought that by enabling scientists to build a model of the brain, artificial neural networks allowed scientists to observe what is happening inside, including how brains make productive mistakes. Rather than being black boxes, researchers believed these systems could open this black box of the mind and let scientists peer inside and see all the messy stuff that was really happening.

But there was another camp in the world of AI who thought that creative thinking was just “normal” thinking done better. It is interesting to look at these two very simplistic heuristics for understanding intelligence and creativity, and how they do and don’t mesh. The debate, then, was about trying to determine what human inventiveness boils down to, and then how to reconstitute human inventiveness in machine form. 

Q: How did these early computer engineers view AI, and how is it different from the way we think about AI today?

A: When we think of AI systems, we think of ChatGPT or Claude. We value and use these systems because they give answers that, most of the time, are correct. One of the things that was most interesting to me in this research was finding out that a lot of the early advocates of these systems valued them for exactly the opposite reason. They wanted a system that, on occasion, gave answers that deviated from their expectations. They already had systems that could deliver reasonable and expected answers. They saw neural networks as valuable because they could give unexpected, perhaps even strange and bizarre answers.

One reason we might view these systems differently today could be because of how they operate. Early on, these systems were confined to laboratories, so there weren’t really any real-world consequences of a system that gives a strange, or wrong, output. But now there are legal and monetary reasons why OpenAI or Anthropic doesn’t want a chatbot that gives unexpected or creative answers. There has been a “sanding down” of strangeness in these systems. They still potentially have that at their core, but it is something that is now largely suppressed.

Q: How did early neural networks that incorporated randomness to simulate human creativity evolve to become the dominant paradigm in AI?

A: For a long time, a specific kind of AI called “symbolic AI” was the dominant approach. Essentially, symbolic AI says the world is based on rules. The role of the AI researcher is to try and reconstruct the knowledge of the world in facts and propositions and feed it into a computer.

Neural networks, with their use of randomness to solve problems, started to gain traction in the 1950s but fell out favor early on. Frank Rosenblatt, a psychologist who was a very important early figure in neural networks, died prematurely; he died accidentally on his 43rd birthday in 1971. He was quite a charismatic and forceful personality, who made a lot of grand promises about what systems based on neural networks could do. By the time he died, a shift toward symbolic AI was already underway. It is possible if, had he lived, things might have turned out differently.

But neural networks never went away. By the 1980s they had shifted more into the world of cognitive science. To become more powerful, and more useful, neural networks needed a lot of data and computational power. That didn’t really arrive until the advent of the internet, when a lot of data became available and computing started to power up. Around 2012, neural networks started to outperform and outpace a statistical form of machine learning, and they kept growing from there.

Q: What lessons can we learn from studying AI’s history that could inform its development? 

A: I think there is a cautionary lesson here. The ideas and experiences of these early engineers tell us that we can work toward quashing hallucinations — we can work toward making AI perform a certain way so it doesn’t produce unexpected or unwanted answers — but there are going to be other consequences of that. These historical figures were onto something. There is a connection between the surprising and creative conclusions AI can offer and errors or hallucinations. There are tradeoffs when we build our systems to behave one way or the other. Maybe it is impossible to be completely at either end of the spectrum, but when we work toward one thing robustly, we often sacrifice something else unintentionally.

正文保留英文原文,标题与摘要由机器翻译。

本文由采集器自动同步

原文发布于 MIT News AI(Q&A: How AI came to model the “messy” human mind),标题、摘要与正文由机器翻译,术语按行业惯例统一,未经人工逐句校订。

阅读原文 ↗