11-20 更新 实时
首页/ 算力市场/ 正文

专家评论:为何众多 AI 工具最终走进 AI 坟场

算力市场 来源:TechXplore 2026-11-20 10:00 0 阅读 机器翻译
专家评论:为何众多 AI 工具最终走进 AI 坟场

继续使用 Google、Facebook 或 Apple,即表示您同意使用条款。

专家评论:为什么这么多 AI 工具最终走进了 AI 坟场?

作者:Philippa Webb,牛津大学

编辑:Lisa Lock,审阅:Andrew Zinin

本文已按照 Science X 的编辑流程与政策进行审阅。编辑在确保内容可信度的同时,着重指出了以下特性:

添加到首选来源

在各国政府与科技公司竞相开发 AI 之际,一个更根本的问题正在浮现:由谁来塑造这项技术,又有谁能从中受益?无论技术多么出色,除非人们相信它是与用户共同打造、并为用户而建,否则一款 AI 工具始终难以被接受。

技术研究公司 Gartner 发现,截至 2025 年底,至少有 50% 的生成式 AI 项目在概念验证阶段之后被放弃。2024 年的一项研究将 AI 项目的失败率定为超过 80%,是不涉及 AI 的技术项目的两倍。

在 AI 与司法系统这一领域,风险尤其高。DoNotPay 曾把自己宣传为“全球首个机器人律师”,如今它同意支付 193,000 美元,以和解美国联邦贸易委员会就其能力提出的指控——这些能力宣称并未经过充分测试。

斯坦福大学的研究人员还发现,法律 AI 研究工具,包括 LexisNexis 的 Lexis+ AI 和 Thomson Reuters 的 Ask Practical Law AI,“产生幻觉的比例在 17% 到 33% 之间”。在法庭上,一个错误可能让人失去自由,一款如此频繁出错的工具,无法仅靠技术宣称或效率提升赢得信任。

巴西拥有全球最雄心勃勃的司法 AI 项目之一,它已经认识到,热情可能很快超出实际采用的速度。据巴西国家司法委员会称,该国法院已采用 178 项 AI 举措,但到 2023 年,65% 的司法 AI 项目已被中止。这引发了关于 AI 项目如何获得支持、协调和持续的重要问题。从一开始就让将要使用这些工具的人参与其中,是确保它们满足真实需求、赢得信任并经受时间考验的重要一环。

从外部强加的技术,很少能在与真实生活的接触中存活下来

对于技术工具被强加而非共同创造会发生什么,阿富汗提供了重要教训。在 20 年和 1450 亿美元的重建成本之后,美国的一项调查得出结论:美国政府难以让自己的努力契合阿富汗的具体情况,也未能考虑阿富汗机构能否维持这些努力。

数字项目也遵循了同样的轨迹。2019年,USAID的承包商DAI受托为喀布尔市政府开发一款公民上报应用。该项目没有与喀布尔居民共同设计,而是要求把一款为危地马拉一个小镇打造的应用改造过来,以节省时间和成本。这款应用于2020年10月上线,随即就闲置了。

“只有当人们感到安全、有信心用它来与政府互动时,公民技术才能真正可持续,而这种信任是通过与社区共同创造建立起来的。随着政府转向AI,这一点愈发重要。这个过程没有捷径,”Oxford Institute of Technology and Justice技术专家Sara Wahedi表示。

即便是世界级的AI,也可能在诊所门口栽跟头。Google Health构建了一个深度学习系统,能够通过视网膜扫描以超过90%的准确率检测糖尿病眼病。然而,当Google的研究人员跟随它进入泰国的11家诊所时,光线不佳等实际挑战意味着,该系统会拒绝一些它原本或许能够识读的图像。模型在实验室里有效,但它并未与将要使用它的护士共同设计。

当社区参与构建工具时,他们会让它持续运转

反例来自新西兰的最北端。Te Hiku Media是一家iwi(部落)广播电台,它请自己的社区帮助构建te reo Māori(毛利语)的语音识别。短短10天内,约2500人贡献了310小时的语音与文本配对数据。该系统目前在te reo Māori上的准确率达到92%,并以Kaitiakitanga许可证发布,该许可只允许将数据用于毛利人的利益。Te Hiku还拒绝了寻求获取这些语言数据的公司。技术上的卓越紧随共同创造而来,这个先后顺序奏效了。

资助方和产业界开始注意到这一点。Gates Foundation 表示,“当 AI 工具所要服务的人群帮助塑造这些工具时,它们才最有效”,而 Microsoft AI for Good Lab 的负责人则表示,当 AI 是“与所服务社区共同构建、并为其而建”时,它可以扩大司法服务的可及性。这种日益增长的认识是一个令人鼓舞的步骤,有助于让共创成为 AI 项目资助和开发方式中更成熟的一部分。

在 Oxford Institute of Technology and Justice,我们正在为妇女和儿童、一线响应人员、记者和法官构建工具,并与他们共同构建。我们还在推出一项关于“通过共创引领 AI”的高管项目。

根据我们的经验,共创做三件重要的事。第一,它检验资助方想要解决的问题是否就是人们实际经历的问题。第二,它建立信任,把人们被告知要使用的工具,变成他们主动选择使用的工具。第三,它确保可持续性;在资助结束、顾问离开后,人们有切身利益让系统继续运行。

在马拉维,我们的共创会议让一线响应人员——包括护士、教师、治安法官书记员和庇护所管理者——能够帮助选择该工具的功能,该工具旨在帮助获取有关童婚和性暴力的法律信息。一位参与者表示,因为她参与了共创该工具温暖而令人安心的声音和语气,所以她“对它有一种主人翁感”。

倾听必须从一开始就进行,共同创造环节必须写入预算和时间表,关键绩效指标也必须考虑人们是否会持续使用所构建的东西。社区未曾参与塑造的 AI 工具,无论工程技术多么出色,终将不断被送进坟墓。

这篇报道背后是谁?

艺术史学士,物质文化硕士。曾任博物馆编辑、急救员和移植协调员。自 2021 年起为 Science X 担任编辑。完整简介 →

物理学硕士,拥有科研经历。资深科学新闻爱好者。在 Science X 的编辑工作中发挥关键作用。完整简介 →

引用:专家评论:为什么这么多 AI 工具最终进了 AI 坟墓?(2026 年 11 月 19 日)于 2026 年 11 月 19 日检索自 https://techxplore.com/news/2026-11-expert-comment-ai-tools-graveyard.html

本文受版权保护。除为私人学习或研究目的的合理使用外,未经书面许可不得复制任何部分。内容仅供参考。

“没有问责,没有制衡,没有责任”:原住民如何看待 AI

AI 或可帮助扩大人道主义救援的规模。但它也可能带来重大弊端

弥合差距:AI 如何助力——或阻碍——可持续发展目标

资助方承诺投入 10 亿美元,为一线工作者开发 AI 工具

评论:司法系统中使用的 AI 应保留“人在回路”

开源微控制器为可穿戴设备与机器人集成传感、存储和无线工具

脑研究人员让 LLM 遭受类似中风患者的“损伤”,以解析 AI 语言机制

六英寸机器人可检查常规摄像头无法触及的核废料管道

从仙人掌中收集电能

合则更佳:两种金属与一种墨水如何重塑印刷储能

少量锰就能让下一代电池大不相同

获取即时摘要文本(要点)

当工具不符合用户需求、工作流程或本地条件时,AI 项目即使技术表现强劲也可能失败。司法和医疗领域的例子凸显了可靠性和实施障碍。与目标用户共同设计有助于建立信任、促进采用和持续使用,但不能取代技术验证。

本摘要由 LLM 自动生成。完整免责声明

译文由英文原文机器翻译,术语按行业惯例统一,可在文末展开原文核对。

查看英文原文(Expert comment: Why do so many AI tools end up in the AI graveyard?)

By continuing with Google, Facebook or Apple, you agree to the Terms of Use.

Expert comment: Why do so many AI tools end up in the AI graveyard?

by Philippa Webb, University of Oxford

edited by Lisa Lock, reviewed by Andrew Zinin

This article has been reviewed according to Science X's editorial process and policies. Editors have highlighted the following attributes while ensuring the content's credibility:

Add to Preferred Sources

ai chip Credit: Pixabay/CC0 Public Domain

As governments and technology companies race to develop AI, a more fundamental question is emerging: who gets to shape the technology, and who benefits from it? However brilliant the technology, an AI tool will always struggle to be accepted unless people believe it was built with them and for them.

Gartner, a technology research firm, found that by the end of 2025 at least 50% of all generative AI projects had been abandoned after the proof-of-concept stage. A 2024 study put the failure rate for AI projects at more than 80%, twice that of technology projects that do not involve AI.

When it comes to AI and justice systems, the stakes are especially high. DoNotPay, which marketed itself as the "world's first robot lawyer," agreed to pay $193,000 to settle charges brought by the U.S. Federal Trade Commission over claims about its capabilities that had not been adequately tested.

Researchers at Stanford also found that legal AI research tools, including LexisNexis' Lexis+ AI and Thomson Reuters' Ask Practical Law AI, "hallucinate between 17% and 33% of the time." In a courtroom, where an error can cost someone their liberty, a tool that is wrong so often cannot earn trust through technical claims or efficiency gains alone.

Brazil, home to one of the world's most ambitious judicial AI programs, has learned that enthusiasm can quickly outrun adoption. Its courts have adopted 178 AI initiatives, according to the National Council of Justice, yet 65% of judicial AI projects had been discontinued by 2023. This raises important questions about how AI projects are supported, coordinated and sustained. Involving the people who will use these tools from the outset is an important part of ensuring they meet real needs, earn trust and stand the test of time.

Technology imposed from outside rarely survives contact with real life

Afghanistan offers important lessons for what happens when tech tools are imposed rather than co-created. After two decades and $145 billion in reconstruction costs, a U.S. investigation concluded that the U.S. government had struggled to tailor its efforts to the Afghan context or consider whether Afghan institutions could sustain them.

Digital projects followed the same arc. In 2019, USAID's contractor DAI commissioned a citizen-reporting app for Kabul Municipality. Rather than designing it with Kabul's residents, it called for adapting an app built for a small town in Guatemala to save time and money. The app launched in October 2020 and immediately lay dormant.

"Civic technology only becomes sustainable when people feel safe and confident using it to engage with their government, and that trust is built through co-creation with the community. As governments turn to AI, this matters even more. There are no shortcuts to this process," said Sara Wahedi, technology specialist, Oxford Institute of Technology and Justice.

Even world-class AI can stumble at the clinic door. Google Health built a deep learning system that could detect diabetic eye disease from retinal scans with more than 90% accuracy. Yet when Google's researchers followed it into 11 clinics across Thailand, practical challenges such as poor lighting meant the system rejected images it might otherwise have been able to read. The model worked in the lab but had not been designed with the nurses who would use it.

When communities build the tool, they keep it running

The counterexample comes from New Zealand's far north. Te Hiku Media, an iwi radio station, asked its community to help build speech recognition for te reo Māori. Within 10 days, roughly 2,500 people had contributed 310 hours of paired speech and text. The system now reaches 92% accuracy for te reo Māori and is released under a Kaitiakitanga license, which allows the data to be used only for the benefit of Māori people. Te Hiku has also turned away corporations seeking access to the language data. Technical excellence followed co-creation, and the sequencing worked.

Funders and industry are beginning to take notice. The Gates Foundation states that "AI tools are most effective when the people they are meant to serve help shape them" while the head of Microsoft's AI for Good Lab has stated that AI can expand access to justice when it is "built with and for the communities it serves." This growing recognition is an encouraging step toward making co-creation a more established part of how AI projects are funded and developed.

At the Oxford Institute of Technology and Justice, we are building tools for and with women and children, first responders, journalists and judges. We are also launching an executive program on Leading AI through Co-Creation.

In our experience, co-creation does three important things. First, it tests whether the problem a funder wants solved is the problem people actually experience. Second, it builds the trust that turns a tool people are told to use into one they choose to use. Third, it ensures sustainability; people have a stake in keeping the system running after the grant ends and the consultants leave.

In Malawi, our co-creation sessions have enabled first responders, including nurses, teachers, magistrates' clerks and shelter managers, to help choose the features of the tool designed to help access legal information on child marriage and sexual violence. One participant observed that because she was involved in co-creating the warm and reassuring voice and tone of the tool, she "feels a sense of ownership over it."

Listening has to take place from the outset, co-creation sessions have to be written into budgets and timelines, and key performance indicators must consider whether people keep using what was built. AI tools that communities had no hand in shaping will keep ending up in the graveyard, however good the engineering.

Who's behind this story?

Lisa Lock

BA art history, MA material culture. Former museum editor, paramedic, and transplant coordinator. Editing for Science X since 2021. Full profile →

Master's in physics with research experience. Long-time science news enthusiast. Plays key role in Science X's editorial success. Full profile →

Citation: Expert comment: Why do so many AI tools end up in the AI graveyard? (2026, November 19) retrieved 19 November 2026 from https://techxplore.com/news/2026-11-expert-comment-ai-tools-graveyard.html

This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

'No accountability, no checks and balances, no responsibility': How indigenous peoples think about AI

AI could help scale humanitarian responses. But it could also have big downsides

Bridging the gap: How AI can help—or hinder—the Sustainable Development Goals

Funders commit $1B toward developing AI tools for frontline workers

Opinion: AI used in justice system should keep 'humans in the loop'

Open-source microcontroller combines sensing, storage and wireless tools for wearables and robots

Brain researchers afflict LLMs with 'injuries' similar to those of stroke victims to unpack AI language mechanisms

Six-inch robot could inspect nuclear waste pipes beyond reach of conventional cameras

Harvesting electricity from prickly pear cacti

Better together: How two metals and one ink are reshaping printed energy storage

A little manganese makes a big difference for next-generation batteries

Get Instant Summarized Text (Gist)

AI projects can fail despite strong technical performance when tools do not fit users’ needs, workflows or local conditions. Examples in justice and health highlight reliability and implementation barriers. Co-design with intended users can support trust, adoption and sustained use, but does not replace technical validation.

This summary was automatically generated using LLM. Full disclaimer

This site uses cookies to assist with navigation, analyse your use of our services, collect data for ads personalisation and provide content from third parties. By using our site, you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.

原文为英文,正文由自动抓取并保留原文。

本文由采集器自动同步

原文发布于 TechXplore(Expert comment: Why do so many AI tools end up in the AI graveyard?),标题、摘要与正文由机器翻译,术语按行业惯例统一,未经人工逐句校订。

阅读原文 ↗