IEEE 庆祝将伦理纳入 AI 系统十周年

面向技术内幕人士
面向技术内幕人士
IEEE Spectrum 是 IEEE 的旗舰出版物——IEEE 是全球最大的致力于工程与应用科学的专业组织。我们的文章、视频和信息图表向读者介绍技术、工程和科学领域的最新进展。
创建账户,即可享受更多免费内容和权益
保存文章以便稍后阅读,需要拥有 IEEE Spectrum 账户
The Institute 的内容仅会员可访问
下载完整 PDF 期刊仅限 IEEE 会员
下载本电子书仅限 IEEE 会员
Spectrum 数字版的访问权限仅限 IEEE 会员。
关注话题是 IEEE 会员专属功能。
加入全球最大的专注于工程与应用科学的专业组织,即可访问 Spectrum 的全部文章、档案、PDF 下载及其他权益。进一步了解 IEEE →
加入全球最大的专注于工程与应用科学的专业组织,即可获取这本电子书,以及 IEEE Spectrum 的全部文章、档案、PDF 下载及其他权益。进一步了解 IEEE →
查阅数千篇文章——完全免费
创建账户即可获得专属内容与功能:收藏文章、下载合集、发表评论——全部免费!如需完整访问权限与全部权益,请订阅 Spectrum。
IEEE 庆祝将伦理纳入 AI 系统十周年
标准与认证助力打造具有社会责任感的产品
Kathy Pretz 是 IEEE 会员刊物《The Institute》的主编。
政策制定者、技术专家和公众都对 AI 的快速进步可能给社会带来的危害表示担忧。他们的担忧包括偏见、侵犯数据隐私、错误信息传播,以及失去对 AI 智能体的控制。
对许多人来说,这些问题相对陌生,但 IEEE 标准协会(IEEE Standards Association)在过去十年里一直在研究如何优先推动 AI 系统的负责任开发。
2016 年,IEEE SA 发起了 IEEE 自主与智能系统(A/IS)伦理考量全球倡议,并发布了《伦理对齐设计》(Ethically Aligned Design,EAD)报告。EAD 的使命是鼓励所有参与自主与智能系统设计的人,将伦理考量应用于造福人类,从而优先关注人类福祉。
该报告由来自全球的多学科专家社群共同编写,为 A/IS 提出了八项基本原则,其中包括人权、民众福祉和透明度。100 多位顶尖 AI 伦理专家提供了意见。EAD 的第二版报告于 2017 年发布。据该全球倡议的创始执行董事、现任 IEEE Planet Positive 2030 全球总监的 John C. Havens 介绍,两个版本都公开征集意见,并收到了数百页反馈。到 2019 年,贡献者已超过 400 人,且该社群仍在持续壮大。
Havens 表示:“从某种意义上说,《伦理对齐设计》是同类报告中的第一份——它不只是一份原则清单,而且出自 IEEE 这样具有公信力的组织。在该报告发布时,还没有任何类似的东西。”
自发布以来,一系列标准相继制定,为设计、构建和部署以人类价值为先的技术提供实用指南。多个 AI 伦理认证项目也已推出。
今年是 EAD 首版草案发布 10 周年。为庆祝这一节点,IEEE SA 近期上线了一个网站、一档播客系列和一个博客,回顾该报告的成就与影响。
八项指导原则
根据 EAD 的首版,伦理一词常与道德混用,但在负责任的 AI 系统设计中并非如此。该报告融合了经典伦理学传统与基于价值的设计方法的洞见,为开发 AI 工具的工程师提供可落地的建议。
该报告为设计自主系统确立了八项基础性一般原则:尊重人权;将增进福祉作为开发成功的评判标准;赋予个体数据自主权以掌控自身身份;有效性;透明性;可问责性;对滥用的警觉;以及系统创建者应具备的能力。
作者写道,这些原则将应用伦理前移到 AI 系统的设计阶段,而非等系统发布后才加以关注。
IEEE 7000 系列标准正是在 EAD 框架的基础上制定出来的。目前该系列包含 29 个项目,其中 11 项已经发布,还有更多仍在陆续加入。这些标准涵盖的议题包括:伦理系统设计模型流程(IEEE 7000-2021)、AI 系统透明度(IEEE 7001-2021)、数据隐私(IEEE 7002-2022)、算法偏见考量(IEEE 7003-2024)、对人们福祉的影响(IEEE 7010-2020)、机器可读的个人隐私要求(IEEE 7012-2025),以及模拟人类共情的系统(IEEE 7014-2024)。
AI 伦理认证
IEEE SA 提供了一整套 AI 伦理项目,其中包括 IEEE CertifAIEd,该认证分为两类:一类面向个人,一类面向产品。
这项专业认证为个人提供相应技能,使其能够评估自主与智能系统是否符合 IEEE 的方法论和伦理标准。
“《以伦理为导向的设计》(Ethically Aligned Design)是同类中的第一份——它不只是一份原则清单,而且出自像 IEEE 这样具有公信力的组织。”——John C. Havens,该全球倡议的创始执行董事
产品认证项目评估的是某个组织的 AI 工具或系统是否符合 IEEE 本体规范中的标准。认证评估师(CertifiAIEd assessor)会评估该产品,以确保其满足这些标准。评估完成后,所有者将评估结果提交给 IEEE 合格评定项目(IEEE Conformity Assessment Program),后者可对其进行认证并颁发认证标志。
IEEE SA 近期还发布了面向儿童的负责任 AI 认证项目(Responsible AI for Children)。该项目认证面向儿童的 AI 产品已经过独立测试与验证,符合设计与伦理要求。
新的行业联系小组
IEEE 人工智能系统(AIS)促进全球繁荣协作产业汇编小组的成立,旨在为 AI 系统开发者提供所需的资源、知识和工具,以将人们的福祉置于优先位置。该小组拥有 200 多名成员。
该协作组织将其工作描述为一种务实、系统层面的负责任技术设计框架,把“繁荣”转化为可在 AIS 全生命周期中使用的应用方法、度量指标和工具。
该小组正在制定相关准则,用于指导如何设计、评估和治理那些能够可衡量地改善人类福祉与生态可持续性的系统。
各分委员会分别聚焦认知、教育、信仰、地球关怀、灵性及其他议题。
“该小组直接基于《合乎伦理的设计》中的福祉章节以及 IEEE 7010 标准(《评估自主与智能系统对人类福祉影响推荐实践》)开展工作,”Havens 表示。“这是有意为之,因为如果在设计中不首先考虑人类与地球的繁荣,那么人类福祉和地球可持续性就会成为事后才想到的事。”
为纪念十周年,IEEE SA 制作了五集播客系列《合乎伦理的设计:影响的十年》。该系列于 10 月 21 日上线,每两周发布一集新节目。
各集内容围绕 EAD 的愿景、其基本原则的遴选过程,以及这些原则如何被转化为 IEEE 7000 系列标准展开。
第一档播客《Origins of Ethically Aligned Design》探讨了早期让伦理成为 AI 与自主系统设计中实用组成部分的努力。专家们讨论了其中的挑战、争论、全球协作,以及推动负责任技术从伦理原则走向可落地标准与实践的实际影响。
第二档播客《The Chapters and Committees》聚焦于那些致力于把广泛的人类价值观转化为 AI 与自主系统实用指南的多学科团队。
这些播客讨论为一项思想领导力项目提供了素材,该项目还包括关于 IEEE 7000 系列的博客文章和教育资源,以持续提升人们对这项开创性工作的认知与支持。
译文由英文原文机器翻译,术语按行业惯例统一,可在文末展开原文核对。
查看英文原文(IEEE Celebrates 10 Years of Incorporating Ethics Into AI Systems)
FOR THE TECHNOLOGY INSIDER
FOR THE TECHNOLOGY INSIDER
IEEE Spectrum is the flagship publication of the IEEE — the world’s largest professional organization devoted to engineering and applied sciences. Our articles, videos, and infographics inform our readers about developments in technology, engineering, and science.
Enjoy more free content and benefits by creating an account
Saving articles to read later requires an IEEE Spectrum account
The Institute content is only available for members
Downloading full PDF issues is exclusive for IEEE Members
Downloading this e-book is exclusive for IEEE Members
Access to Spectrum 's Digital Edition is exclusive for IEEE Members
Following topics is a feature exclusive for IEEE Members
Join the world’s largest professional organization devoted to engineering and applied sciences and get access to all of Spectrum’s articles, archives, PDF downloads, and other benefits. Learn more about IEEE →
Join the world’s largest professional organization devoted to engineering and applied sciences and get access to this e-book plus all of IEEE Spectrum’s articles, archives, PDF downloads, and other benefits. Learn more about IEEE →
Access Thousands of Articles — Completely Free
Create an account and get exclusive content and features: Save articles, download collections, and post comments — all free! For full access and benefits, subscribe to Spectrum .
IEEE Celebrates 10 Years of Incorporating Ethics Into AI Systems
Standards and certifications foster socially responsible products
Kathy Pretz is the editor in chief of The Institute, IEEE's member publication

Policymakers, technologists, and members of the public have raised concerns about the harm AI’s rapid advancement might cause to society. Their concerns include bias, data privacy violations, the spread of misinformation, and losing control of AI agents.
Those issues are relatively new to many people, but the IEEE Standards Association has been working for the past decade on ways to prioritize the responsible development of AI systems.
In 2016 IEEE SA launched the IEEE Global Initiative for Ethical Considerations in Autonomous and Intelligent Systems (A/IS) and published the Ethically Aligned Design report. EAD’s mission is to encourage everyone involved in designing autonomous and intelligent systems to prioritize human well-being by applying ethical considerations for the benefit of humanity.
Developed by a multidisciplinary community of experts from around the world, the report outlined eight foundational principles for A/IS. They include human rights, people’s well-being, and transparency. More than 100 leading AI ethics experts provided input. EAD’s Version II report was released in 2017. Both versions solicited public input and received hundreds of pages of feedback, according to John C. Havens, who was the global initiative’s founding executive director, and is now the global director for IEEE Planet Positive 2030. And by 2019, there were more than 400 contributors and the community continues to grow.
“Ethically Aligned Design was the first of its kind in the sense of a report that was more than a list of principles and from an organization with the credibility of IEEE,” Havens says. “At the time it was released, there wasn’t anything like it.”
Since its launch, a series of standards has been developed to provide practical guidelines on designing, building, and deploying technology that prioritizes human values. Several AI ethics certification programs have been introduced.
This year marks the 10th anniversary of EAD’s first draft. To celebrate, IEEE SA recently launched a website, a podcast series, and a blog that reflect on the report’s achievements and impact.
Eight guiding principles
The word ethics is often used interchangeably with morality, but that is not the case in responsible AI systems design, according to EAD’s first version. The report includes insights from classical ethics traditions and value-based design methodologies to offer actionable recommendations for engineers developing AI tools.
The report established eight foundational general principles for designing autonomous systems: respecting human rights, prioritizing increased well-being as success criteria for development, empowering individuals with data agency to have control over their identity, effectiveness, transparency, accountability, awareness of misuse, and competence for the system creators.
The principles shift applied ethics to the design stage of AI systems, compared with being a concern after they’re released, the authors wrote.
The IEEE 7000 series of standards has been developed based on EAD’s framework. Currently the series consists of 29 projects, 11 of which have been published, and more are still being added. They cover topics such as ethical system design model process (IEEE 7000-2021), AI system transparency (IEEE 7001-2021), data privacy (IEEE 7002-2022), algorithmic bias considerations (IEEE 7003-2024), the impact on people’s well-being (IEEE 7010-2020), machine-readable personal privacy requirements (IEEE 7012-2025), and systems that mimic human empathy (IEEE 7014-2024).
AI ethics certifications
IEEE SA offers a suite of ethics in AI programs including IEEE CertifAIEd, which includes two certifications: one for individuals and one for products.
The professional certification provides individuals with skills to assess autonomous and intelligent systems for adherence to IEEE’s methodology and ethics criteria.
“Ethically Aligned Design was the first of its kind in the sense of a report that was more than a list of principles and from an organization with the credibility of IEEE.” —John C. Havens, founding executive director of the global initiative
The product certification program assesses whether an organization’s AI tool or system conforms to the criteria in the IEEE Ontological Specifications. A CertifiAIEd assessor evaluates the product to ensure it meets the criteria. Upon completion of the assessment, the owner submits it to the IEEE Conformity Assessment Program, which can certify it and issue the certification mark.
IEEE SA also recently released its Responsible AI for Children certification program. This program certifies that AI products for children have been independently tested and verified to meet design and ethics requirements.
New industry connections group
The IEEE Artificial Intelligence Systems (AIS) for Global Flourishing Collaborative Industry Collections group was formed to provide the resources, knowledge, and tools needed to prioritize people’s well-being to developers of AI systems. It has more than 200 members.
The collaborative describes its work as a practical, systems-level framework for responsible technology design that translates flourishing into applied methods, metrics, and tools that can be used throughout the AIS lifecycle.
The group is establishing guidelines for how to design, evaluate, and govern systems that can measurably improve human well-being and ecological sustainability.
Subcommittees are focused on cognition, education, faith, planetary care, spirituality, and other issues.
“The group is building directly off the well-being chapter of Ethically Aligned Design and the IEEE 7010 standard (Recommended Practice for Assessing the Impact of Autonomous and Intelligent Systems on Human Well-Being),” Havens says. “That’s on purpose because if human and planetary flourishing aren’t addressed first in design, then human well-being and planetary sustainability are afterthoughts.”
To mark the 10-year anniversary, IEEE SA created the five-part “Ethically Aligned Design: 10 Years of Impact” podcast series. It launched on 21 October. New episodes are being released every two weeks.
The episodes center around the vision for EAD, the process for selecting its foundational principles, and how they were translated into the IEEE 7000 standards.
The first podcast, “Origins of Ethically Aligned Design,” explored early efforts to make ethics a practical part of AI and autonomous system design. The experts discussed challenges, debates, global collaboration, and the real-world impact that helped move responsible technology from ethical principles toward actionable standards and practices.
The second podcast, “The Chapters and Committees” focuses on the multidisciplinary groups that worked on turning broad human values into practical guidance for AI and autonomous systems.
The podcast discussions serve as material for a thought leadership program that also includes blog articles about the IEEE 7000 series and educational resources to continue to raise awareness and support of this groundbreaking work.
Related Articles Around the Web
原文为英文,正文由自动抓取并保留原文。
原文发布于 IEEE Spectrum AI(IEEE Celebrates 10 Years of Incorporating Ethics Into AI Systems),标题、摘要与正文由机器翻译,术语按行业惯例统一,未经人工逐句校订。