FAA新SMART AI系统疑问重重,官员称与停飞无关

继续使用 Google、Facebook 或 Apple,即表示你同意使用条款。
围绕 FAA 新推出的 SMART AI 系统疑问不断,不过官员称其与航班停飞无关
作者:Barbara Ortutay 与 Josh Funk
本文已按照 Science X 的编辑流程与政策进行审核。编辑在确保内容可信度的同时,强调了以下属性:
添加到首选来源
2026 年 11 月 13 日星期五,美国联邦航空管理局(FAA)下令全国航班停飞后,一名男子在纽约拉瓜迪亚机场查看航班信息显示牌。图片来源:AP Photo/Ryan Murphy
据政府官员以及该技术背后的人工智能公司称,自周五以来对出行造成严重混乱的航班停飞,与 FAA 正在推广的、耗资 8.75 亿美元的新 AI 系统无关,该系统用于帮助预测空中的问题。
但此次停飞的时机恰逢美国联邦航空管理局的 SMART 系统在全国范围推广之际,这引发了诸多疑问:该系统究竟做什么、与现有的人工系统相比有哪些益处和风险,以及有哪些防护机制来应对潜在问题。
官员称与地面停飞无关
SMART 系统部署在华盛顿附近的一处单一地点,由一支专家团队在那里分析航班时刻表、天气预报以及数百条其他数据流。随后该办公室向 FAA 的指挥中心提交建议,指挥中心再将其转达给全国各地的空中交通管制员供其参考。
国土安全部长 Markwayne Mullin 周五表示,没有迹象显示导致地面停飞的通信问题与这套新计算机系统有关,交通部和 FAA 的最高官员周六也重申了这一说法。
2026 年 11 月 13 日周五,在美国联邦航空管理局下令全国所有航班停飞后,一名男子在纽约拉瓜迪亚机场查看航班信息显示屏。图片来源:AP Photo/Ryan Murphy
设计该系统的初创公司 Air Space Intelligence(ASI)表示,地面停飞并非由“SMART 系统、ASI 的任何产品,或我们与 FAA 及 ATC 的集成”造成。
但在周五的地面停飞之前,议员和外部团体就已对 SMART 系统提出质疑。上个月,众议院民主党人致信美国政府问责局,要求对这款新软件进行审计,并对安全性和防护机制表示担忧。
“令人担忧的是,全美一线的航空安全工作人员显然对 SMART 的开发几乎没有或完全没有参与,并且在当前的部署过程中只获得了有限的培训和资料,”10 月 13 日的这封信写道。“SMART 中人工智能的使用理所当然地引发了对其可靠性和安全效益的严重质疑,尤其是它可能干扰经验丰富的空中交通管制员的决策,或就事关安全的关键信息产生幻觉。”
不过,SMART 至少目前并未设置为由 AI 负责飞行管制。相反,它是向负责飞行管制的人类提供建议。
2026 年 11 月 14 日星期六,在联邦航空管理局下令全国航班停飞后,弗吉尼亚州阿灵顿的罗纳德·里根华盛顿国家机场显示着一块航班时刻显示板。图片来源:AP Photo/Tom Brenner
SMART 系统是什么?
交通部长 Sean Duffy 和 FAA 局长 Bryan Bedford 于 9 月公布该系统,称其为“一款前沿工具,能把 200 路数据流——包括天气模式、飞行航路、交通流量和管制员配备指标——集中到一个平台上”。SMART 是 Strategic Management of Airspace, Routes and Trajectories(空域、航路与轨迹战略管理)的缩写。
根据该公告,系统的 AI 支持引擎会综合这些数据系统,并显示飞机将飞往何处、系统能处理多少流量以及拥堵或天气可能在何处造成问题的“全面可视化”视图。其构想是,专家随后利用该平台在问题出现之前加以解决。
FAA 表示,今年秋天该系统在华盛顿地区进行初步测试期间,共帮助 180 架航班改道,通过绕开天气或其他问题,平均每架航班节省 10 分钟和 80 加仑(303 升)燃油。该机构称,得益于该系统的建议,有一架航班从佛罗里达州坦帕飞往达拉斯的行程缩短了 42 分钟。
因此,SMART 于 11 月 10 日扩展至全国范围使用,覆盖全部 22 个空中交通管制中心的空域。而这距离那次地面停飞仅过去三天。
根据政府关于该工具的情况说明文件,SMART 可以预测空中交通的走向,并在某一区域变得过于拥堵之前识别出其他航路。该系统还能帮助更快地重新开放受限空域,并更好地管理机场进港。
SMART 本也应当更快地协助处理与天气相关的问题。
根据该情况说明文件,目前 FAA 将受天气影响的空域划为“大块矩形区域”予以封锁,这并不能反映天气的实际形态——快速移动的雷暴和风暴系统“往往形状不规则,中间存在狭窄的间隙或走廊,飞机本可以安全穿越”。
为解决这一问题,SMART 为 FAA 和空域运营方提供了“天气将如何随时间影响空中交通的更清晰图景”,使空中交通管制员能够围绕风暴进行规划,利用可用空域,而不是不必要地关闭大片区域。
据前 FAA 空域管理人员、安柏瑞德航空大学副教授 Michael McCormick 称,没有其他国家拥有像 SMART 这样可实际运行的 AI 空中交通工具。欧洲空中交通管理机构 Eurocontrol 有一套系统正在测试中,另有多家制造商正在试制类似工具。
对依赖 AI 的担忧
尽管政府官员以及 SMART 背后的公司 ASI 都强调,其 AI 系统的设计初衷是辅助人类,而非执行飞行控制,但鉴于即便是最先进的模型也容易出现幻觉——即模型编造虚假信息并将其当作事实呈现——该系统投入部署仍引发了人们的担忧:在关乎人命时是否应当依赖人工智能。
Mike O'Donnell 曾是 FAA 的高层官员,在该机构工作了 17 年,如今从事航空安全咨询工作。他表示,该机构“必须确保这只是在工具箱里的一件工具,而不是真正在做这项工作的机器”。
他说,FAA“在这件事上承受不起出错”。
“在配有适当防护机制和兜底措施、确保不会基于(AI)生成的内容向管制员提供错误信息的前提下,使用它是好事,”O'Donnell 说。“必须有一种方式去核验和确认它所做的,确保它给出的不是错误信息。”
他提醒不要对 AI 寄予过多信任,“直到我们确定它已一次又一次地证明了自己。而这需要一段时间”。
该 AI 系统上线之际,全美长期存在空中交通管制员短缺问题。美国国家空中交通管制员协会十多年来一直在提出这一问题,并在 2015 年向国会表示,短缺已达危机水平。该协会当时称,FAA 已连续五年未能达成招聘目标。该工会代表约 14,000 名管制员,其中约 3,000 人为学员。
尽管如此,专家表示,没有任何 AI 系统能够取代那些为这份高要求、高压力工作训练多年的人类空中交通管制员。
在 10 月接受 NPR 采访时,ASI 联合创始人兼 CEO Phillip Buckendorf 表示,SMART 工具是为管理整个美国空域的交通管理人员设计的。
“AI 负责计算,AI 负责运算,”Buckendorf 对 NPR 说,但最终是否采纳系统的建议由人类操作员决定。“他们来做决定,他们是决策者,他们是裁判。”
这篇报道的作者是谁?
物理学硕士,具备科研经历。长期热衷于科学新闻。在 Science X 的编辑工作中发挥关键作用。完整简介 →
引用来源:围绕 FAA 新推出的 SMART AI 系统的疑问不断,尽管官员称其与地面停飞无关(2026 年 11 月 16 日),2026 年 11 月 16 日检索自 https://techxplore.com/news/2026-11-swirl-faa-smart-ai-link.html
本文受版权保护。除为私人学习或研究目的进行的合理使用外,未经书面许可不得以任何形式复制本文任何部分。内容仅供参考。
随着天空愈发繁忙,AI 能否帮助空中交通管制员保障飞机安全飞行?
全球峰会前夕,航空公司瞄准 AI 的“新前沿”
驾驶舱警告系统能否防止美国机场飞机之间的险情?
随着无人机交通量增加,研究人员转向 AI 以帮助避免碰撞
原文较长,译文为节选;译文由英文原文机器翻译,术语按行业惯例统一,可在文末展开原文核对。
查看英文原文(Questions swirl around FAA's new SMART AI system, though officials say no link to ground stop)
By continuing with Google, Facebook or Apple, you agree to the Terms of Use.
Questions swirl around FAA's new SMART AI system, though officials say no link to ground stop
by Barbara Ortutay and Josh Funk
This article has been reviewed according to Science X's editorial process and policies. Editors have highlighted the following attributes while ensuring the content's credibility:
Add to Preferred Sources
A person looks at a flight information board at LaGuardia Airport in New York, Friday, Nov. 13, 2026, after the Federal Aviation Administration grounded flights nationwide. Credit: AP Photo/Ryan Murphy
The airline ground stop that has wreaked havoc on travel since Friday was not related to the FAA's new $875 million AI-powered system the agency is rolling out to help predict problems in the sky, according to government officials and the artificial intelligence company behind the technology.
But the timing of the ground stop, so close to the national rollout of the Federal Aviation Administration's SMART system, has raised questions about what the system does, its benefits and risks compared with the existing human system and what guardrails there are to address potential problems.
Officials say no connection to ground stop
The SMART system is based in a single location near Washington where a team of experts analyzes flight schedules, weather forecasts and hundreds of other streams of data. Then that office sends recommendations to the FAA's command center, which relays them to air traffic controllers across the country for consideration.
Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin said Friday there's no indication the communications issues that caused the ground stop are linked to the new computer system, and the top officials at the Transportation Department and FAA reiterated that Saturday.
A person looks at a flight information board at LaGuardia Airport in New York, Friday, Nov. 13, 2026, after the Federal Aviation Administration grounded all flights nationwide. Credit: AP Photo/Ryan Murphy
The startup that designed the system, Air Space Intelligence, or ASI, said the ground stop wasn't caused by "the SMART system, any product of ASI or our integration with FAA and ATC."
But lawmakers and outside groups raised questions about the SMART system before Friday's ground stop. Last month, House Democrats sent a letter to the U.S. Government Accountability Office requesting an audit of the new software, raising concerns about safety and guardrails.
"Concerningly, the nation's front-line aviation safety workforce apparently had little to no input into SMART's development and has received limited training and information during the current deployment process," the Oct. 13 letter said. "The use of artificial intelligence within SMART has rightfully raised serious questions about its reliability and safety benefits, particularly on its potential to interfere with decision-making by experienced air traffic controllers or to hallucinate safety-critical information."
SMART, however, is not—at least not yet—set up for AI to be in charge of flight control. Rather, it is making recommendations to humans who do so.
A flight schedule board is displayed at Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport in Arlington, Va., after the Federal Aviation Administration grounded flights nationwide, Saturday, Nov. 14, 2026. Credit: AP Photo/Tom Brenner
What is the SMART system?
Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy and FAA Administrator Bryan Bedford unveiled the system in September, calling it a "cutting-edge tool that centralizes 200 data streams—including weather patterns, flight paths, traffic flow and controller staffing metrics—into one platform." SMART stands for Strategic Management of Airspace, Routes and Trajectories.
The system's AI-supported engine synthesizes the data systems and shows a "comprehensive visualization" of where planes are going, how much traffic the system can handle and where congestion or weather could cause problems, according to the announcement. The idea is for specialists to then use the platform to fix problems before they arise.
The FAA says that during the initial test of the system in the Washington area this fall, the system helped reroute 180 flights and saved an average of 10 minutes and 80 gallons (303 liters) of fuel per flight by diverting around weather or other issues. The agency said that one flight cut 42 minutes off its trip from Tampa, Florida, to Dallas thanks to the system's recommendations.
So SMART was expanded for use nationwide on Nov. 10 for the airspace of all 22 air traffic control centers. That was three days before the ground stop.
According to a government fact sheet on the tool, SMART can predict where air traffic is headed and identify other routes before an area becomes too congested. The system can also help reopen restricted airspace faster and better manage airport arrivals.
SMART is also supposed to help with weather-related issues faster.
Currently, the FAA blocks off portions of airspace affected by weather as "large, rectangular boxes," according to the fact sheet, which doesn't reflect how weather actually looks, with quick-moving thunderstorms and storm systems that are "often irregular in shape, with narrow gaps or corridors that aircraft could safely fly through."
To help with this, SMART gives the FAA and airspace operators a "clearer picture of how weather will affect air traffic over time," allowing air traffic controllers to plan around storms and use available airspace instead of unnecessarily shutting down large areas.
No other country has a working AI air traffic tool like the SMART system, according to Michael McCormick, a former FAA airspace manager and an associate professor at Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University. Eurocontrol, the European air traffic authority, has a system in testing and several manufacturers are prototyping similar tools.
Concerns around relying on AI
While government officials and ASI, the company behind SMART, have stressed that its AI system is designed to assist humans and not run flight control, its deployment has raised concerns about relying on artificial intelligence when human lives are at stake, given that even the most advanced models are prone to hallucinations—when models fabricate false information and present it as fact.
Mike O'Donnell, a former top FAA official who worked for the agency for 17 years and now does aviation safety consulting work, said the agency "has got to make sure that this is just a tool in the toolbox and not the actual machine that's doing the work."
The FAA, he said, "cannot afford to be wrong on this."
"It's good to use it with the proper guardrails and backstops to ensure that they're not giving wrong information to controllers based on what (AI) has come up with," O'Donnell said. "There's got to be a way to verify and validate what it's doing to make sure that it's not the wrong information."
He cautioned against putting too much trust in AI "until we know for sure that it's proven itself time and time again. And that's going to take a while."
The AI system's launch comes amid a longstanding shortage of air traffic controllers around the country. The National Air Traffic Controllers Association has been raising concerns about this for more than a decade, telling Congress in 2015 that the shortage was at a crisis level. It said then that the FAA had missed its hiring targets for five years in a row. The union represents about 14,000 controllers, roughly 3,000 of them trainees.
That said, experts say no AI system can replace the human air traffic controllers who spend years training for this highly demanding and stressful job.
In an October interview with NPR, ASI co-founder and CEO Phillip Buckendorf said the SMART tool is designed for traffic managers who manage the entire U.S. airspace.
"The AI does the math, the AI does the computation," Buckendorf told NPR, but it's ultimately up to the human operator whether to take the system's recommendation. "They make the decision, they are the decider, they are the judge."
Who's behind this story?
Master's in physics with research experience. Long-time science news enthusiast. Plays key role in Science X's editorial success. Full profile →
© 2026 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed without permission.
Citation: Questions swirl around FAA's new SMART AI system, though officials say no link to ground stop (2026, November 16) retrieved 16 November 2026 from https://techxplore.com/news/2026-11-swirl-faa-smart-ai-link.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.
As the skies get busier, will AI help air traffic controllers keep planes flying safely?
Airlines eye 'new frontier' of AI ahead of global summit
Could a cockpit warning system prevent close calls between planes at US airports?
As drone traffic increases, researchers turn to AI to help avoid collisions
An AI pilot may be able to navigate crowded airspace
Robots recognize the shape of an arena by messaging each other
Tesla opens Cybercab sales to 'select customers'
Hydropower study reveals energy potential in Appalachia
AI models can answer differently when told they are being watched
Water-based batteries store more energy in iodine with new electrolyte design
New AI 'copilot' lets engineers guide structural designs as algorithms create them
Get Instant Summarized Text (Gist)
SMART integrates air traffic and weather data to recommend routes, while humans retain control. Initial testing reportedly saved an average of 10 minutes and 80 gallons of fuel per rerouted flight. Officials report no evidence linking it to the ground stop, but concerns remain about reliability, validation and controller training.
This summary was automatically generated using LLM. Full disclaimer
This site uses cookies to assist with navigation, analyse your use of our services, collect data for ads personalisation and provide content from third parties. By using our site, you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
原文为英文,正文由自动抓取并保留原文。
原文发布于 TechXplore(Questions swirl around FAA's new SMART AI system, though officials say no link to ground stop),标题、摘要与正文由机器翻译,术语按行业惯例统一,未经人工逐句校订。
